4 ms·
If you're unlucky, you end up with http://www.nytimes.com/1995/12/29/world/a-120-year-lease-on-life-outlasts-apartment-heir.html http://www.nytimes.com/1995/12/
by Someone 10y ago
If you're unlucky, you end up with http://www.nytimes.com/1995/12/29/world/a-120-year-lease-on-life-outlasts-apartment-heir.html http://www.nytimes.com/1995/12/29/world/a-120-year-lease-on-... (1995):
"Andre-Francois Raffray thought he had a great deal 30 years ago: He would pay a 90-year-old woman 2,500 francs (about $500) a month until she died, then move into her grand apartment in a town Vincent van Gogh once roamed.
But this Christmas, Mr. Raffray died at age 77, having laid out the equivalent of more than $184,000 for an apartment he never got to live in.
On the same day, Jeanne Calment, now listed in the Guinness Book of Records as the world's oldest person at 120, dined on foie gras, duck thighs, cheese and chocolate cake at her nursing home near the sought-after apartment in Arles, northwest of Marseilles in the south of France."
- hvm 10y agoSo she lived in a nursing home for 10 years but still didn't let the guy live in the apartment? I know she had the right to it but come on...
- tomp 10y agoIf she wanted to give someone money, wouldn't it be better to give it to the poor?!
- outside1234 10y agoHe has no rights to the house until she dies. This is perfectly within her contract with him.
- mathattack 10y agoSo she can get his payments, and money from a subletter? I guess it's part of the game.
- st3v3r 10y agoYes, it is. It's still also her being a douche.
- coldtea 10y agoContract rights have nothing to do with the morality of this...
- biot 10y agoThe morality is already clearly established: in exchange for a very small monthly sum, you get the property when the owner dies. The property may be a dedicated rental unit already, so whether or not the owner lives there has no bearing. So it's not just _within_ the contract, it's the _purpose_ of the contract.
- coldtea 10y ago>The morality is already clearly established: in exchange for a very small monthly sum, you get the property when the owner dies. That's, again, the contract. Seems some people can't tell between legal and moral, unless we talk about the 70s and segregation or something like that...
- timroy 10y agoNo, I (and presumably the other posters) can tell the difference - I just disagree on the morality, partly because I think the legal aspects are related to the moral aspects. The guy purchased the right to the house once the current owner dies, but you believe it's immoral for her to continue living in it, or renting it out, or loaning it to friends, while she is alive. I think it's immoral to demand the house while she's alive, since that wasn't the deal. Sometimes legality and morality are widely separated, but here they seem related.
- Someone 10y agoIt is a lottery with two participants that willingly took part in it. She won big, but if she had died the day after the contract was signed, he would have won big: he would have gotten the house for about $500. Would you suggest he should have paid her inheritance a lump sum if that would have happened?
- 10y ago
- dopamean 10y agoYou'd think the contract would say that in addition to being alive you have to actually live in the house as well. Otherwise you could just sublet it out and have someone else pay you for it while you live somewhere else. Seems kind of counter to the intention of the idea.
- gypsy_boots 10y agoI guess that is the risk for this approach. This could almost be the premise for an Edgar Allan Poe poem. It's almost too perfect
- teh_klev 10y agoHN discussion on that story from a wee while back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11367422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11367422