5 ms·
Energy STORAGE is a huge bottleneck issue for anyone that follows renewable energy news as well... Solar power itself has been cheap enough to be viable for a
by walrus01 10y ago
Energy STORAGE is a huge bottleneck issue for anyone that follows renewable energy news as well... Solar power itself has been cheap enough to be viable for a long time, 330W 72-cell panels for roofs have been $0.64/watt for several years now. You can quite economically cover the roof of a building in enough high-efficiency 60 or 72-cell panels to generate far more kWh in a year than the building will consume in the same year, but the problem is storage for when the sun isn't shining. It's easy to produce 1600kWh/month from solar panels on a roof, if your house only consumes 1200-1400kWh/month, but you need to use many of your 1200-1400 kWh/month at night.
Off grid energy storage has been severely hampered by the lifecycle cost of $ per kWh stored. Lead acid batteries suck, lithium ion/liPo has until very recently been very expensive in $/kWh. Other energy storage systems have been limited in scale or are only feasible at very specific places, such as large scale pumped-storage hydroelectricity.
If the cost of $$$/kWh stored comes down far enough, it will be entirely possible to build a home that has no connection to the electrical grid at all. Assume this prototypical home is in an American city where electricity from the grid costs 8 cents per kWh. If you make a refrigerator sized battery low enough cost it may be possible with TODAY's cost of solar panels to have a lifecycle cost of 6 cents per kWh consumed. While simultaneously having the effect of making that home energy-independent from the grid and the whole thing being its own immense UPS.
The powerwall is the first step towards this.
- tirant 10y agowe have two options here: We either improve the power grid all around the world, so whenever it's dark in one side of the planet, the other side, sunny, feeds the darker part; or we start investing heavier on other renewable sources not depending on the sun, to provide the required energy for those nights and cold evenings in the the winter months.
- outworlder 10y agoHow do the LiFePo batteries used in current electric cars change the equation? Not so great energy density, but can withstand an immense number of cycles.
- jacquesm 10y agoConversion losses and cost / KWh are the problem nowadays, not the number of cycles, that's getting to the point where it is still a factor but not the factor.
- jacquesm 10y agoRoughly the same dynamics that relate cloud apps vs self hosted apps to reliability relates solar power and grid power to reliability. The grid is - for now - the cheapest battery there is, and it gives you immediate redundancy. It will be far more reliable than anything you install on your roof and in your basement on a per-case basis, even if a grid outage takes down your whole neighborhood, town, or even country. Batteries, at whatever price you pay for them are a really in-efficient way to store and retrieve energy compared to the grid.
- walrus01 10y agoThe thing is, the grid from the perspective of an average residential user is actually not that reliable. In many places in the Pacific Northwest where trees fall on power lines in winter storms the grid does not meet five nines reliability (52 minutes or less outage per year). A properly implemented whole-building off grid battery system and a few inverters running in parallel can be much more reliable than this. The grid is subject to all sorts of failure modes from trees, landslides, flooded vaults and things involving the environment, while a PV system has no moving parts (perhaps except from a ventilation fan in an inverter), and a larger set up can be run with several inverters in parallel providing AC for a building.
- jacquesm 10y agoIf you're still using above ground power lines for local distribution then that definitely would make a difference when it comes to reliability. Just like in Northern Ontario where our solar/wind homebrew solution was a lot more reliable than the local grid. Even so, in a developed country that's a choice, not a necessity.
- cma 10y agoIsn't it really cloudy in the Pacific Northwest during winter?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jseliger 10y agoEnergy STORAGE is a huge bottleneck issue for anyone that follows renewable energy news as well Very true, but, interestingly, large-scale electric vehicle adoption may help this: http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2016/05/09/3775606/used-second-life-electric-car-batteries/ http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2016/05/09/3775606/used-sec... as lightly used car batteries may cease being attractive for use in cars but be very attractive in terms of base-load storage.
- walrus01 10y agoAbsolutely. It's all about the $/kWh stored. A "worn out" electric car battery might have only 70% of its cycle depth/capacity remaining compared to when it was new, but if the battery packs can be acquired for very cheap, that doesn't matter so much. There is a guy with videos on youtube who has purchased battery packs from crashed Tesla Model S and retrofitted an old volkswagon bus for 100+ mile EV range.
- outworlder 10y agoYes. He also had some packs made from salvaged battery cells. And a battery trailer, inspected by the DMV.
- beamatronic 10y agoI would like to know more! Is this the incident in question? http://insideevs.com/diy-project-salvaged-tesla-model-s-to-underpin-stretched-volkswagen-vanagon-body-wvideo/ http://insideevs.com/diy-project-salvaged-tesla-model-s-to-u... "Joe’s “donor” Model S will be brought back to life by Otmar in the form of a stretched Volkswagen Vanagon called Strechla. The Vanagon will exist only on the outside. On the inside, underside and everywhere in between, you’ll find Model S." edit: added more words
- walrus01 10y agoit's this guy: https://www.youtube.com/user/jehugarcia/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/jehugarcia/videos scroll down a bit into the older videos and you will see the VW.
- msandford 10y ago> but you need to use many of your 1200-1400 kWh/month at night As air conditioning, but there are other solutions! Ice has neigh-infinite charge/discharge cycles and big institutions have been doing this for years. If your "campus" is more than a few hundred tons of AC it's probably cooled by ice. It's not been terribly economical to do this at a small scale but as solar gets cheaper and batteries don't there are people working on the problem. https://www.ice-energy.com/technology/ https://www.ice-energy.com/technology/
- nl 10y agoFlow Batteries[1]! They work (as in: are being used in Africa & South America to power mobile networks). Also my (office) building is powered by one. They don't cost much more than lead-acid They last much, much longer than lead-acid or lithium* There is no limit to the number of power cycles(!!) and they can be deep-discharged. They do have disadvantages - they aren't suitable for cars, and are currently fairly noisy when cycling, and have lower power density than lithium* batteries. They also need to be periodically complete discharged (although most have software to make sure each individual cell does this as part of the normal use) Disclaimer: An investor in Redflow owns my building (hence the power source)[2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery [2] http://redflow.com/ http://redflow.com/
- Yaggo 10y agoInteresting, haven't heard about such batteries being commercially sold. Any idea who sells those for private consumers in Europe?
- nl 10y agoI believe Redflow will have a consumer offering this year, (under another brand). Not sure about European availability.
- beefield 10y agoNot sure about the private consumer part in Europe, but following seems to be in Austria: http://www.bluesky-energy.eu/project/redflow-zinc-bromide-battery/?lang=en http://www.bluesky-energy.eu/project/redflow-zinc-bromide-ba...
- mavhc 10y ago167 Wh/l = 167kWh per cubic metre, say 16 hours of no sun, 16kW output at night, seems reasonable
- nl 10y agoYep. Next time someone claims base load means renewables don't work do that math. Also point to the experience in developing countries where they don't have reliable base load, yet have similar uptime.
- Teeboo 10y agoThis is one of the most optimistic and best things I have read in weeks. +1