4 ms·
My personal belief is we fixate on things like plane bombings and child abductions because we are out of touch with the world in the given respect. We understa
by sliverstorm 17y ago
My personal belief is we fixate on things like plane bombings and child abductions because we are out of touch with the world in the given respect.
We understand there is a risk to driving a car, and accept it. To some extent we are deadened to it, forget about it (which is why I occasionally force myself to remember the risks) but we also intuitively understand the risk is low. You don't see an accident but every 6 months or a year, and most people are involved in them far less, yet we drive nearly every day.
Planes and abductions are different. We don't fly every day; we don't have an understanding of just how many flights happen, so we don't realize how low the odds actually are- we fixate on the downed plane, and in our minds we see 1 out of 1- 100% failure. Now, there are some exceptions like 9/11, where the risk is low but the cost is massive, possibly offsetting the low risk. That, on the bright side, can be approached differently (perhaps give the pilots weaponized doorways, or completely seal the door during flight. Institute a policy of 'go ahead and kill your hostage, we aren't going to crash this plane into the Empire State' [it is crucial to make the hostage NOT the pilot]. It's cruel, but if you crash the plane everyone and more are dead anyway, and without trained guards on-board there's not even a ghost of a chance you can fight the hostage free.)
Abductions are the same way; we are not aware how many children travel around on a daily basis and as such do not realize the relative size of the odds. This one also has an extra spice mixed in though- we are worried about somebody else, and we are not there. I find, at least for me, it's much easier to accept risk for myself esp. when I am involved in the situation, than it is to accept risk to someone else, ESP. when I am not involved in the situation.
- redcap 17y agoThat and while a large number of us drive, very few of us fly the plane - we have to entrust that duty to another person. That person may be very well trained, but is normally not someone you know. Flying is also fairly unnatural for humans - it's at its heart rather dangerous, and it's thanks to the skill and training of the individuals involved that make it a safe way to travel. Conversely, while we do get a fair amount of training to drive a vehicle, it's nowhere near the amount of checking and cross-checking that a pilot goes for. The nearest I do is "mirror-indicator-headcheck" when crossing lanes, and "if I have to think about whether it's dark enough to turn on my headlights, it's time to turn them on". While the actual risk involved with flying may be low, that's because it's been reduced in practice a heck of a lot, but that's often not visible to the public.
- roundsquare 17y agoThat seems like it might point the way to a solution. Lets make it obvious. I'm not sure how, but lets show how much training pilots get, how much rigor goes into making an airplane, how many checks an balances go into it, how many people are involved, the number of man hours, the number of tests, etc... Of course, this doesn't apply to the kidnapping situation... but maybe some kind of information campaign can do the trick there to.