3 ms·
What's the benefit of flying carpet over just having the ad in the content? Judging from the gif in the article it is basically just and image added in-line of
by wodenokoto 10y ago
What's the benefit of flying carpet over just having the ad in the content?
Judging from the gif in the article it is basically just and image added in-line of the article, except it has a bit if parallex scrolling effects.
Seems less annoying than a sticky ad.
- jbob2000 10y agoThe benefit is that you can show a larger ad in a smaller space. Since screens are super small on mobile, advertisers need a way to show you big eye-catching ads without disturbing the content too much.
- Blaaguuu 10y agoMaybe it just catches the eye more, because it doesn't move with the rest of the content as you scroll. It's harder to just scroll past without noticing it...
- rpgmaker 10y agoAMP always was such an obvious way to end run adblockers. How are carpet ads less annoying than a popup? On mobile I dread accidentally tapping almost anything so this is a troubling development.
- wodenokoto 10y agoI wouldn't compare it to a pop-up (at least not from the animation in the article) but it looks very much like a big in-line ad only the content has a gap that reveals the ad, instead of the ad being placed in the same, scrolling column as the content. So how is this more troubling than an in-line ad?
- shostack 10y agoI'd consider it more of a mobile interstitial. Interstitials in general are regarded as pretty invasive. But frankly the Google mobile SERP has turned into a big interstitial these days with ads taking up the entire first screen in may cases, requiring you to scroll to see any actual organic results.
- randomguy7788 10y agosince amp is normal html, ad blockers still work
- shostack 10y ago- Greater visibility (since you can take up most of the screen) - Likely a much higher chance of accidental clicks (not a good thing for advertisers, but that won't stop people from claiming this format has a higher CTR) - Focuses your attention way more on the ad. Instead of something that just scrolls by super quickly with the flick of a thumb, until you get to the next block of content, the image itself is static, so your brain can parse it even in the couple of seconds it is on the screen because it is not actually moving.
- cramforce 10y agoWe spent a lot of time making accidental clicks unlikely (and making sure that scrolling on the ad scrolls the page) One other benefit is that because the ad is on a parallax pane, it can resize itself without disrupting the page flow (which AMP does not allow).
- shostack 10y agoAre you on the team that made these new formats? I'd love to know what sorts of things you do to avoid accidental clicks. I assume click location relative to the frame of the unit is part of it, and possible pausing to wait for swipe activity to confirm a click, but would really be interested in knowing more (I'm a buy-side ad guy). Unfortunately, Google isn't the only one with this format, and on many pages I've had false clicks when scrolling through this format. To most users, they will have no clue whether this is a Google ad or not, and I'd be shocked if they didn't equate bad experiences with every network, regardless of whose ad was actually misbehaving.
- cramforce 10y agoI'm the tech lead of the AMP project. Our work was mostly related to ensuring that native scrolling of the main page works as expected when the finger touches the ad iframe. This is non-trivial and most implementations do it by forwarding touch events from the ad up to the page, which then feels laggy and leads to touches that are interpreted as clicks.