2 ms·
The problem with your reasoning is that we have actually have lots of historical experience with what it is like when we don't license doctors. It was awful.
by gojomo 17y ago
The problem with your reasoning is that we have actually have lots of historical experience with what it is like when we don't license doctors. It was awful.
Yes, but lots of things were 'awful' in that same era. Science and medicine were cruder; people were less educated; people were poorer; communication options were slow and limited.
Now we know more, are richer, and have instant worldwide communication and deep searchable public databases. Lots of the old paternalism, even if once justified, can now be discarded.
But also: even the welfare gains we might think were from licensing, because they occurred after the licensing was introduced, may have instead been from the same rising wealth/standards/awareness that triggered the demand to "do something".
Consider for example the trend in workplace deaths, before and after the creation of OSHA to improve occupational safety:
http://divisionoflabour.com/archives/004409.php http://divisionoflabour.com/archives/004409.php