3 ms·
Then the debate seems pretty nonsensical. Even though it's touted as somehow having appeal. ( http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/#7 http://plato.stanford
by pas 10y ago
Then the debate seems pretty nonsensical. Even though it's touted as somehow having appeal. ( http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/#7 http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/#7 )
The concept is used as an argument against physicalism, because it might be logically possible (concievable).
Maybe I'm just testifying about how closed my mind is, but to me the answer is a simple no, they are not [not even coherent], end of debate, go think about ethics, at least that seems hard.
Dualists are so full of abstract possibilities since Descartes that they are somehow overlooking the difference between imagination-fueled word-soup of consciousness and real problems of consciousness.
Qualia is the noise in our cognition when our brain tries to make sense of the noise in our feelings when we try to consider what's this feeling consicous thing.
It's real, and it's nothing, and it's pretty personal, because some people don't really care about it, others build entire philo departments on it :)
- aninhumer 10y ago>The concept is used as an argument against physicalism, I don't see it as an argument against anything, it's just an interesting philosophical hypothetical made plausible by our inability to observe conciousness. I could certainly see an argument that they're not that interesting on a more practical level (since by definition, we can never apply any conclusions made about them) but I don't understand the suggestion that they're logically incoherent.