5 ms·
I find voice assistants rather underwhelming. I tend to lob them really specific questions they should be able to answer like. "call $business_thats_part_of_a
by dsfyu404ed 10y ago
I find voice assistants rather underwhelming. I tend to lob them really specific questions they should be able to answer like.
"call $business_thats_part_of_a_national_chain in $town $state." That's a batting practice pitch right over the plate. The "in $town $state" tells it to use Google maps search. From there it should have no problem finding the business and phone number. Instead it tells me "here's what we found for $business in $town $state." Of course the first result is the business I'm looking for and I can find and call the number somewhere on the page but it's almost easier to just Google it directly.
The only time I'm willing to put up with this is when I'm driving and want to minimize interaction with the phone.
Maybe nobody uses them in public because it's faster, more precise and less obnoxious to type.
Looking up car parts would be nice ( "does $chain_store in $town have $partnum" and "$other_chain_stire in $next_town_over have $partnum") is hilariously easy from a implementation perspective since everything but slapping the voice recognition on top and mapping key words to software commands has been solved for a long time. (e.g. http://showmetheparts.com/ http://showmetheparts.com/).
- zippergz 10y agoRight. The voice assistant doesn't currently solve a real problem I have, except in a few limited situations (in the car, when my hands are full, etc.). And even then I don't trust it enough to do the right thing.
- djrogers 10y ago> hilariously easy from a implementation perspective since everything but slapping the voice recognition on top and mapping key words to software commands has been solved for a long time. Yes, any single capability is 'hilariously easy' to implement - the problem with these systems is that there are thousands of capabilities to implement before people can consider them close to doing 'everything'.
- Duhck 10y agoThis is why truly horizontal AI is 20 years away IMHO
- jklinger410 10y agoI really wish companies would stop redefining things like AI just for marketability. It's leading people to believe that real AI programming is occurring regularly.
- CaptSpify 10y agoWould there be a better term for this? I know nothing of AI, but it seems like it should still be categorized as AI, but at a much lower level?
- WorldMaker 10y agoI remember this discussion from school. Textbooks have defined most of the experiments and tools of the AI boom of the '60s as "AI": things like neural nets and even basic "expert systems" such as today's phone trees. Individually, these things aren't really AI, but even today most of them are fundamental component parts in the larger discussion... What is the "atomic theory" of AI? Are all of these pieces and components evolutionary explorations into AI or something less or something different? What do we call them along the way other than just "AI"?
- Duhck 10y agoIt's machine learning and NLP which is not AI (and thus I agree)
- transpy 10y agoWhen I watched the Google Home video from the I/O event, I cringed very hard. And I am not a skeptic: I generally am a believer in new tech, in natural language tech, etc., but that video looked really goofy and improbable. Do they really think that families are going to change their morning routines to interact via voice with a device? Just the "Hello Google" command is awkward enough, people aren't going to walk down the street while talking nerdy Google commands out loud. I don't see it happening. And from a foreign language speaker standpoint, I find it even harder to imagine. In Spanish there is not really a consensus about how to pronounce 'Google'. I can't imagine people on the streets speaking Googlish. On the other hand, everyone googles, for sure, everyone uses search and mobile. I have the feeling that these two interactions -text/type search and mobile- are too hard to improve on. I don't think voice has a chance to become bigger than text.
- stvswn 10y agoHave you observed anyone interact with Alexa? I have, and it seems like people really love it. So, is there a big difference between Alexa and Google Home that you find dealbreaking, or do you challenge the notion that Alexa has been successful?
- transpy 10y agoI haven't. I would like to try it out, maybe I will check the browser emulation they released a couple of weeks ago. I would like to try it both in English and Spanish and compare the experiences.