6 ms·
Why is Economist pushing the narrative that Innocence of Muslims had anything to do with the embassy attack and murder of the US Ambassador in Libya when that c
by zaroth 10y ago
Why is Economist pushing the narrative that Innocence of Muslims had anything to do with the embassy attack and murder of the US Ambassador in Libya when that cover story was completely debunked?
- daveguy 10y agoSeems like the facts listed in the first paragraph are substantial indications for it having at least something to do with the attack. It wouldn't be the first time or the last time extremist muslims reacted violently. Do you have a source for that complete debunking? Edit: The article as a whole isn't about just that incident either. It is about the growing suppression of speech from regimes of all kinds.
- ones_and_zeros 10y agoIt is the corner stone of the Benghazi investigations. HRC wrote in an email that they "knew" the attack was planned and had nothing to do with the video yet kept repeating that it was because of the video to the public. Her defense was pretty pathetic. [0] [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/10/22/transcript-clinton-testifies-before-house-committee-on-benghazi/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/10...
- lifty 10y agoexcuse my ignorance, but could you elaborate a bit on that.
- vanattab 10y agohttp://www.factcheck.org/2012/10/benghazi-timeline/ http://www.factcheck.org/2012/10/benghazi-timeline/ I am not sure I buy the whole cover up story totally. But I do think it was handled poorly by the Administration because they thought it would be convenient to portray the events through a particular political lens. Even if the attacks were motivated in some small way by the video have we really gotten to the point of blaming the filmmakers for murders committed by people offend by the flim? I don't care how "in poor taste" the film is.
- simonh 10y agoIt's a shame the article contains that flaw, but I don't think removing it materially damages the overall argument.
- tomp 10y agoSource? (I actually have no idea what caused the attack on the embassy.)
- ohitsdom 10y agoSecretary of State Hillary Clinton: "we know the attack in Libya had nothing to do with the film. It was a planned attack, not a protest." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Benghazi_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Benghazi_attack
- tomp 10y agoJust because the attack was planned doesn't mean that it had nothing to do with the movie. From the article you linked to: > Captured suspect Ahmed Abu Khattala stated that the assault was indeed in retaliation for the video Innocence of Muslims
- dragonwriter 10y agoIt wasn't debunked. While, unlike the attacks at US embassies in Egypt, Yemen, Indonesia, and other US diplomatic and cultural facilities in the same week (and protests without attacks at many more), there were no protests at the Embassy in Libya (and some early reports had tied the attacks to nonexistent protests about the film), numerous eyewitnesses did report that the attackers claimed to be motivated by the film, and while the later claim of responsibility from al-Qaeda claimed a different retaliatory motivation, it's also al-Qaeda (al-Qaeda central, not regional affiliates, in both cases) that was behind the hijacking of previously planned protests over a different issue in Egypt to focus on the film that culminated in the attack on the US embassy in Egypt. The only thing that was debunked were the early reports of protests in Benghazi, that the film played a role in motivating the attacks was never debunked.
- jessaustin 10y agoThis seems pretty tenuous, but still it raises questions. The video is still on Youtube. Why were all the "protests" over within a month? Why don't they continue to this day? (I have other questions, but they veer even further into the realm of politics, so I'll keep those off HN.)
- maze-le 10y ago> Why were all the "protests" over within a month? Why don't they continue to this day? I think the attention span for those things is rather limited. You can't cry "Outrage!!1!" every day over the same thing again and again and still mobilize people for your cause. This seems to be a rather common phenomenon regardless of the group or cause you support. Also, to organize such a protest, you need people with time and resources to reach out. I assume, that at some point, these people deicide, that it makes more sense to steer resources into other projects.
- mikeash 10y agoIt happens all the time. There's some big event, it gets a lot of attention, the event never goes anywhere but people lose interest and move on. MH370 was never found but the coverage faded away. The Bring Back Our Girls campaign pretty much died out even though no girls were brought back. Everybody was outraged when Russia annexed Crimea, but nobody cares now.