6 ms·
The new theory summarised (from the paper): >The theory begins with attention, the process by which signals compete for the brain’s limited computing resources
by tim333 10y ago
The new theory summarised (from the paper):
>The theory begins with attention, the process by which signals compete for the brain’s limited computing resources. This internal signal competition is partly under a bottom–up influence and partly under top–down control. We propose that the top–down control of attention is improved when the brain has access to a simplified model of attention itself. The brain therefore constructs a schematic model of the process of attention, the ‘attention schema,’ in much the same way that it constructs a schematic model of the body, the ‘body schema.’ The content of this internal model leads a brain to conclude that it has a subjective experience.
Kind of makes sense to me - that the mechanism that forms a model of your body or a place map or whatever also forms a model of your mental setup of senses, memories and the like.
- acqq 10y agoThe higher "awareness" of the environment and the effects of the body's actions to it can obviously be of evolutionary advantage. And the individuals whose awareness better matches the reality will obviously have advantage too.
- veli_joza 10y agoThe same theory was also mentioned in Dawkins' Selfish Gene. The evolution favored individuals that could simulate its surrounding and consequences of its actions better. At certain point, that simulation had to include the individual itself in order to be complete, and that gave way to consciousness. Dawkins called this "simulation", while the article calls it "internal model".
- sridca 10y agoConsciousness is nothing more than an organism being aware of itself. However, where you say "to include the individual itself" - that's a different matter, as now you are talking about the feeling of being a "self" (which is not a prerequisite to be conscious).
- Retric 10y agoTop down control presupposes consciousness, or something really close to it. Sleep / dream memory formation seems like a much more reasonable argument. Sleep without activity can simply tone down brain activity. But, if activity happens during REM sleep you need a brain / body abstraction to avoid sleepwalking via sleep paralysis. At that point you have lot's of brain structures for simulating things that can be run while your awake. Sleep as a means to conserve energy > Sleep as a means to aid learning (replay events for different types of memory formation) > Sleep as a means to simulate options > Simulating options while awake.
- mnkmnk 10y agoI can't help but imagine the brain doing dependency injection to swap in mock walking implementation. :D
- nwah1 10y agoEveryone in this thread sounds like a p-zombie.
- simonh 10y agoSays the guy posting the most p-zombie like post on the entire thread.
- coldtea 10y agoWhat exactly makes it "the most p-zombie like post on the entire thread"? It might be, but we'll never know from mere snark.
- pasquinelli 10y agoa philosophical zombie behaves in every externally observable way the same as a non-zombie, but the philosophical zombie has no inner life. so if you can observe it in other people, for instance, in what they post on the internet, then it isn't pertinent to the philosophical zombie question. everything you can observe then is equally philosophical zombie like.
- jnicholasp 10y agoI wonder if that's completely true, though: that p-zombies behave in every observable way the same as non-zombies. What about in this very discussion of inner life and zombie-ness? Will a p-zombie claim to have subjective experience, or will they be confused by the concept (maybe along the lines of this other comment I replied to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11856232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11856232)
- coldtea 10y ago>in much the same way that it constructs a schematic model of the body, the ‘body schema.’ Sight aside, who said the mind "constructs a schematic model of the body"?
- orasis 10y agoone of those schemes is proprioception. Have you ever noticed how proprioception is hacked when you're driving a car or playing a video game? You become the car. You become Mario.
- coldtea 10y agoThat always involves my sight though. Seeing the car, Mario etc. And the only reason it can work without it when it comes to my own arms and legs etc, is because I get touch, air resistance, etc feedback from them. And even then it comes to my own body, it doesn't work as good as when with vision included -- try shaving with closed eyes for an easy example.
- rosser 10y agoAre you suggesting that the visually impaired somehow have diminished proprioception?
- coldtea 10y agoI guess I am. And even worse for those with impaired sense of touch etc. You say it like it's some kind of preposterous claim.
- rosser 10y agoFrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proprioception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proprioception — emphasis added. "In humans, it is provided by proprioceptors in skeletal striated muscles (muscle spindles) and tendons (Golgi tendon organ) and the fibrous capsules in joints." "A major component of proprioception is joint position sense, which is determined by measuring the accuracy of joint–angle replication. Clinical aspects of joint position sense are measured in joint position matching tests that measure a subject's ability to detect an externally imposed passive movement, or the ability to reposition a joint to a predetermined position. These involve an individual's ability to perceive the position of a joint without the aid of vision."