6 ms·
PCIE slots are limited so when you are talking about actual compute scale the 1070 can be more expensive considering you'll have to get another case, cpu, ram,
by dogma1138 10y ago
PCIE slots are limited so when you are talking about actual compute scale the 1070 can be more expensive considering you'll have to get another case, cpu, ram, and an PSU that can handle 4 cards at max load.
And of course the more components you have in a given system the more likely is that one of the will fail, granted if you are designing a system to be resilient against attrition a system with more lower powered components can be more resilient than a system with fewer more powerful ones based on the performance difference between them and the MTBF for each component.
But bang for buck charts don't mean much even for Gaming I never understood why people even use them, spend what you can and want to get the performance you want.
Spending 50% more to get only 20% more performance is a valid option because those 20% can mean the difference between a playable game at high resolution and a laggy mess.
Traditionally SLI setups for mid range cards could out-perform and be cheaper than high end cards but with a huge caveat - being dependant on the SLI profile for the game, if it come out to be shitty or non-existent you are just stuck with 2 cards that can't really run the game at the settings/resolution you want.
Also unless you are building a small datacenter power consumption can be ignored, the 50-75W difference in total system draw between a mid range and a high end card when the rest of the hardware is the same isn't going to have any financial impact on anyone even if we take the most expensive power in Europe that's going to come out to about 30 cents per KWh.
- kuschku 10y agoEh, the most expensive power in Europe is more at 60ct per kWh. Average in northern Germany is already 38ct per kWh, although this is expected to change with the northern and southern German electricity market being split in the next weeks (Northern Germany has a huge surplus, Southern Germany not nearly enough).
- dogma1138 10y agoEven so we are usually talking about 50W max draw difference between the mid and high end cards is still 20 hours of gaming at max load before you have 60 cents difference between them :P
- BuckRogers 10y agoInteresting. That sounds expensive actually? $0.60US for 20 hours of gaming just for the machine? 60 and 38 cent kWh sounds extremely high. This was my last power bill. As you can see it might average out to $0.05/kWh once you add in the taxes and regulatory fines. Tier 1 first 500 kWh at $0.018 per kWh (winter) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$9.00 Tier 2 next 25 kWh at $0.056 per kWh (winter) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$1.40 Regulatory Charges 525 kWh at $0.01414 per kWh . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$7.42 Community Benefit Charges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$2.91 Power Supply Adjustment 525 kWh at $0.02783 per kWh . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$14.61 Residential Sales Tax Taxable Amount . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$45.34 City Sales Tax 1% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$0.45 TOTAL CURRENT CHARGES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$45.79
- dogma1138 10y agoI was taking the 60cents per KWh price, 50W difference is 1 KWh @ 20h of gaming, 20h of gaming is what the average gamer plays a week so given the gamer with the higher end card will pay 60 cents more per week 30 about 30$ more per year than the one with the mid range card given that all the other parts are identical and they both play 20 hours a week :)
- nikcub 10y agoI agree that for gaming it makes sense getting the higher end cards rather than dealing with SLI, but my use case is password cracking that doesn't require five 9's uptime. The GTX 1070 is 150W power consumption while the 1080 is 180W. Rather than get another case i'd just scale up the case size based on the number of cards - 2 cards ($100[0]) 4 cards ($200[1]), 6 cards ($400[2]) 1200W PSU $300[3], riser cards $10[4] and then motherboard + cpu + SSD about $200-250 so it works out $700 base for 2 GPU system, $900 base for 4 GPU system and $1400 for 6 GPU (2 PSU's) If you work that out with the card options the sweet spot is 4x 1070 GPU's for $1500. It really isn't worth spending $4k on cards to get equiv performance from Titan X's or 15-30% more performance with the 1080 (although power/performance is better). [0] http://www.coolermaster.com/case/mid-tower-cm690-series/cm693/ http://www.coolermaster.com/case/mid-tower-cm690-series/cm69... [1] http://www.corsair.com/en/obsidian-series-900d-super-tower-case http://www.corsair.com/en/obsidian-series-900d-super-tower-c... [2] http://www.miningrigs.net/?product=graymatter-6gpu-server-case http://www.miningrigs.net/?product=graymatter-6gpu-server-ca... [3] http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139039 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139... [4] http://www.amazon.com/Fixable-Adapter-Flexible-Extension-Connector/dp/B00IMYODGS http://www.amazon.com/Fixable-Adapter-Flexible-Extension-Con...
- dogma1138 10y agoWhat motherboard can you buy for under 50 with 6 PCIeX16 (power) slots? The cheap "bitcoin" motherboard that go for about 50-75$(old intel express chipset) won't work in this case, not sure about the 1070 but the 980 (non-ti) and the Titan X do not want to work with any PCIe slot that isn't a true PCIeX16 power slot. The PCIe x1-4 to x6 riser converter boards do not work, even the "good" ones with a SATA power connector and an actual power PCB for some reason, my guess is that there is some actual sensing going on in the card itself. Unless you buy something like this http://www.amazon.com/ASRock-Motherboard-H81-PRO-BTC/dp/B00HEUIS2G?ie=UTF8&keywords=asrock%20bitcoin%20motherboard&qid=1465300259&ref_=sr_1_1&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/ASRock-Motherboard-H81-PRO-BTC/dp/B00H... which which is i think the only non-server motherboard which is commonly available you aren't getting more than 4-4 PCIe slots, and even to get 4 (PCIe16) you need to spend about 200$ on a motherboard these days and the H81 chipset mobo's don't want to work with modern nVIDIA cards (or the other way around) with all but the main PCIe16 slot. Pretty much to get more than 2 PCIx16 slots these days you have to buy a good gaming Z170/Z97/X99 motherboard, that ain't cheap, nor are the CPU's that go into them. While the AMD CPU's might be a bit cheaper again the motherboards won't be. P.S. my personal password cracking setup at home is 4 5970's you could get them for about 100$ even a couple of years ago (today they are much cheaper 2 for 130 or b/o: http://goo.gl/yplISa http://goo.gl/yplISa) and for most hashes they go 40-50% of the perofmrnace of a Titan X (I do have 2 Titan X's in my personal gaming rig which i can use in a pinch). I got them setup on an ASROCK motherboard (h61 iirc) that was designed for bitcoin mining so it comes with 8 PCIE slots and powered converter ribbons connect the cards do it all of this sits in a al cheapo rackmount case of a 20 year old compaq server. But if you are looking for more scalable compute instance AWS CUDA instances are probably a better solution and I've been using them more and more lately.
- varelse 10y agoPhysical space on the motherboard IMO is the true limiting factor here. And this is what made Google's TPU interesting IMO. I don't think it demonstrated world-beating performance, but it likely fit a strict power and size envelope as an add-on board in the their datacenters, hence all the bragging about perf/W without a single absolute performance benchmark.
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>But bang for buck charts don't mean much even for Gaming I never understood why people even use them I've never bough the highest end card for gaming in my life. The price premium is close to double and you get maybe 20-30% the performance. Worse, a lot of that performance is for gaming bragging rights like playing absurdly high resolutions or having very high settings. I can barely tell the difference between high and ultra in most games anyway. Medium to High can also be a crapshoot if medium is at a decently high resolution. Not to mention a lower tier card uses 60-100 watts less, which means I don't need to upgrade my mid-range power supply either. I find that high watt ps's are fairly delicate as well and blow frequently, but that may be only my experience. I have 400 and 500 watt ps's that run for nearly a decade with no issues but every 600+ I've had to buy blows by year two or three. Worse, the cards don't age well. A 980ti isn't going to be good for VR sooner than later because the 1000 series will support a single viewport for both eyes (SMProjection) which means a performance boost of anywhere between 20-50% in VR. You're better off spending your dollars on a 960/970 range card and just pocketing that extra $200-$300 for an earlier upgrade to the next series instead of sitting on the higher version of an old series too long. With SMProjection, even a 1060 is going to outperform a 980ti bought recently for VR. That'll be a $199 card killing a $600 card in VR.
- BuckRogers 10y agoJust to play devil's advocate if I may. Of course the longer you wait the more you get for your money. The difference is you didn't get to enjoy a 980Ti for a long time and someone who bought one did. Money can't buy that, it's priceless. The type of people running a 980Ti probably already have a 1080 anyway. :) While everyone else is snickering about how these wealthy folks somehow lost. People who have a Geforce 1060 budget, probably won't have a HTC Vive either to worry about beating 980Ti VR performance.. I think the PSU thing is anecdotal. Not enough information to explain that either way. I generally go for a decent wattage PSU but worry a lot more about the 12v rail. I've had my existing Corsair HX650 for many years now and among many reasons chose it for 52A single 12v rail. Rock solid PSU. I do agree that just recently has buying less-than-top end has started to make sense. But I disagree that historically that move has been as sensible as it is now. I agree with the OP. I always bought top tier hardware until recently because we actually needed the performance. I always paid the price when stepping down, that 20-30% was needed for a very long time. I've been using 256bit memory bandwidth GPUs since at least 2002. There was a huge gap between them and the lesser tier 128bit stuff. Again, some things are priceless. Every cent I spent on my original 3dfx Voodoo card in 1996 was worth it. Even if I could've saved a few bucks going with a Rendition Verite. Today, not as much as the market has matured if you discount VR. I'm probably done buying high end for desktop machines but I think for decades now, it's been well worth it. Example, I was dismayed at the slow FPS my Geforce 8800GT offered me. When I upgraded to the 8800GTX it was very much worth it. Even so, my PC spending is actually going up though from historic numbers. I'm buying gaming laptops from here on out, something I've never done before. Waiting for a Razer Blade with Geforce 1080M so I can use it with a Vive in a wirefree backpack configuration. Similar story to the above, it's expensive: but can you put a price on completely wireless roomspace VR? Not in my opinion. While I'll likely use this in VR then also have a docking station for it, for my 2nd PC, I'm moving to the Skull Canyon NUC and successors.