2 ms·
What's a few poisoned people in 12,000 years? They're people, is the important point. If nothing else, this is about keeping a clean conscience, knowing that y
by andrewflnr 10y ago
What's a few poisoned people in 12,000 years?
They're people, is the important point. If nothing else, this is about keeping a clean conscience, knowing that you did your best to save them.
- JoeAltmaier 10y ago...and success is measured in minimizing that number. The most effective way might be, to kill interlopers as immediately and unambiguously as possible. Not to attract pilgrims for centuries with mysterious messages and monoliths, who go home to die of unknown sores and blood problems.
- morgante 10y ago> The most effective way might be, to kill interlopers as immediately and unambiguously as possible. How would you make a system which could kill interlopers quickly and reliably 10,000 years from now? Also, killing people is a great way to send the message that "something valuable is here."
- crpatino 10y ago> How would you make a system which could kill interlopers quickly and reliably 10,000 years from now? 1. Put the real stash of waste very, very deep underground. 2. Put a (much smaller) booby stash in a moderately innaccesible place above. People who make it this far should get the first symptoms within one hour and probably die painfully a few weeks later. 3. Leave smaller traces of the stuff laying around in the more accessible areas of the site. Ideally, it should not leak out and should not be easily removable by human means. However, the main goal is to have people getting sick by repeated exposure. Nothing that kills right away, but something that leads to reduced life span and/or quality of life. > Also, killing people is a great way to send the message that "something valuable is here." The point is not to issue any overt warning. People will be smart enough to create a story that fits the scenario. Instead of a fortress made to guard unfathomable riches with ancient evils, you want them to think of us like a bunch of idiots that messed with stuff they did not quite grasp and got Darwinized in the process. There will always be 3Ds jobs: dumb, dirty and dangerous. You masquarade as one of such places and people will not give it a second thought.
- morgante 10y ago> 1. Put the real stash of waste very, very deep underground. What exactly is the benefit of that? If you're willing to poison people, just go ahead and poison them.
- crpatino 10y agoBy the same logic, if you are going to bitch about whatever response you get, why botter asking in the first place? Alternatively, you may want to fetch a dictionary and look up the meaning of word "tradeoff".
- andrewflnr 10y agoThe actual dangerous material is going to be securely buried and contained. The threat model is people disturbing the site, breaking the containment, and releasing radioactive material. The resulting deaths are unlikely to fit the "immediate and unambiguous" profile. It might just slowly kill generations of people settling in the area. Or, it might get into the air and rapidly kill many more people than those nearby. Better to convince them to stay away.