3 ms·
> Does that mean the 'buy locally' idea has little climate impact? No, buy locally has a large climate impact - only not in the direction you think. Local uses
by ars 10y ago
> Does that mean the 'buy locally' idea has little climate impact?
No, buy locally has a large climate impact - only not in the direction you think. Local uses much more energy than non-local.
Local has no environmental benefits whatsoever - only negatives.
The only thing it has going for it is some nebulous social benefits of knowing your farmer.
I avoid local because it means the produce was grown not in the climate where it grows best, but rather forced (i.e. lots of extra resources) to grow near me.
- jestar_jokin 10y agoBut isn't part of the "buying local" movement also buying produce that's in season for your climate? If you're buying local pineapples in Duluth, I can see it would defeat the purpose.
- ars 10y agoEven if it's in season doesn't mean your climate is the best place to grow it. If it was the best place, then it would be competitive on the open market, and produce from your area would be the primary produce on the market - without any hokey social movements.
- jacalata 10y agoThat's only true if you want to claim that the "best" place to grow $randomFruit cannot be more profitably used doing $randomThing. Downtown San Francisco could be the world best microclimate for tomatoes but it still probably wouldn't be worth using the land for that instead of an apartment.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- teslaberry 10y agowhat's amazing is that a generation of brainwashed people have been taught to assume that ordinary course business behavior ( capitalism) is inefficient and that anything with a regime or pattern of buying ( regulatory or luxury price preference for organic) is more efficient. no, capitalism is efficiency. and even when you 'price in' nonsense like carbon dioxide which is neither pollution or a 'cost' to anyone, you are still left with an inferior service or product that uses relatively inefficient means of production. environmentalism in its modern orthodoxy promotes the ideology of economic regression and economic suicide. it's really a shame how a generation has been taught to embrace this as the automatic way to think about problems.