5 ms·
> Any scenario could be possible, from personal revenge to a smear campaign by an intelligence agency. It's also worth being aware of the possibility that Jaco
by geofft 10y ago
> Any scenario could be possible, from personal revenge to a smear campaign by an intelligence agency.
It's also worth being aware of the possibility that Jacob Appelbaum is himself an agent of an intelligence agency (either a plant, or someone turned informant once they realized they could blackmail him and that a creep is a useful informant), and his behavior is a way to maintain his power and in turn the intelligence agency's.
Argument 1: https://inciteblog.wordpress.com/2010/07/15/why-misogynists-make-great-informants-how-gender-violence-on-the-left-enables-state-violence-in-radical-movements/ https://inciteblog.wordpress.com/2010/07/15/why-misogynists-...
Argument 2: https://medium.com/@nickf4rr/hi-im-nick-farr-nickf4rr-35c32f13da4d https://medium.com/@nickf4rr/hi-im-nick-farr-nickf4rr-35c32f...
"But really, I thought, why would Jake be so defensive about some random [lightning talk] that might have otherwise gone completely unnoticed? If I were a government operative hell-bent on destroying the global hacker community, what would I do differently from what Jake is doing now?"
I don't think this is particularly likely over the simpler explanation that he's a non-government-affiliated creep, but if we're going to give credence to "A government agency that hates Tor was behind this," it's worth looking at all the possible ways a government agency might get an advantage out of the situation.
- Chris2048 10y agoWhile conspiracy theory is a risky proposition, in this case the agencies involved are known for such things. COINTELPRO, prism etc, so it's no entirely implausible to raise such concerns.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoHis tactics have been to further publicize things they rely on while also pissing off community members to point that subversion is less likely. I'd say he's doing opposite of what CIA or FBI would want him to do. Whereas, Tor is actually funded by an organization connected to CIA propaganda groups and is used by military intelligence. One is working for spooks, whether harmlessly or not. It's just not Jake that's the one. Strange the conspiracy theories focus on him instead of Tor.
- tptacek 10y agoFirst: no, this is not plausible. Second, a question: exactly what is it that people think Jacob Appelbaum did to make him Public Enemy #1 of any government? He's not an especially important Tor contributor. Tor is not only funded by the US Government, but it began as a project at the Naval Research Lab. He's a spokesperson for Wikileaks, and Wikileaks has gotten itself engaged in serious legal issues with the US Government, but he's far from the only person who's done that, and it's not at all clear why anyone should believe he's ever had an important operational role with WL (as opposed to being an advocate). Why would Appelbaum be singled out for "black ops" like this while Glenn Greenwald is spared? Greenwald had an operational role in leaking intelligence secrets from the US Government; not only that, but he's still sitting on a large cache of documents and gradually leaking them out. A Wired article today suggested that Appelbaum had "close to rock-star status" in the hacker community. Which community would that be? His reputation in the security hacker is minimal; he's known primarily for being known. What's so important about Appelbaum that he'd be a state-level target? For any government?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoGreat analysis. He's seriously among the least likely people to be a sanctioned spy. Maybe potential to be a CI one day ratting on people to avoid time. Anybody is capable of that. Can't imagine anything more.
- tptacek 10y agoIt's not a great analysis. It's a superficial recitation of details about Appelbaum from someone with just a casual acquaintance of who he is. That it would seem to anyone like a great analysis is extremely worrying. It suggests to me that this particular cohort of Internet message board nerds shouldn't be trying to debate this particular topic.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI assumed you did research on the man and topic before posting about it. Turns out it's accidentaly great as it matches detailed write-ups Ive read from multiple authors. Only difference is claimed amount of field-work he did deploying Tor. Some say a lot, some a little. That would make him important in privacy circles but again I get conflicting reports. I studied spooks and black ops a long time, though. They wouldn't waste effort on him.
- artichokeheart 10y agoLately I've been thinking that the whole MRA/gamergate/anti-sjw movement was some kind of PsyOps meant to undermine the Internet, but it felt too crazy conspiracy theoryish. That inciteblog post and this article (http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2013/jun/24/undercover-police-spy-girlfriend-child http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2013/jun/24/undercover-police-...) makes me wonder if I'm right.
- jubalfh 10y agoThat being a conspiracy would be actually quite comforting, wouldn't it? Unfortunately, I think the simpler explanation – that humanity fails at being both human and humane – is more probable.