3 ms·
This is sort of troubling. I think I inadvertently broke the same rules alluded to in the article, i.e. I have a small personal project where I mapped the buil
by paganel 10y ago
This is sort of troubling.
I think I inadvertently broke the same rules alluded to in the article, i.e. I have a small personal project where I mapped the buildings from my Eastern European city which used to be owned by Jewish people before they had been nationalized by the newly-arrived communists in 1948. I use Google Maps for displaying said buildings, and in order to "identify" a name as being Jewish I compared the names of the owners from the nationalization law to the entries from yadvashem.org (given enough matches for a certain name it meant that said person was Jewish).
Now, I didn't do this because I hate Jews, on the contrary, I did it because I am saddened by the loss of the Jewish cultural element from my city (they used to comprise around 10-12% of the city population before WW2, most of them emigrated to Israel by the late 1960s), and wanted to sort of make their presence felt again.
I also wanted to, at some point, map on Google Maps the Jewish cemeteries from my part of the country, which are almost all of them being forgotten and not taken care of (seeing as a former Jewish presence of around ~700,000 in the 1930s now only numbers ~3,000). But this article makes me think twice. What if someone thinks I would do that only for some Nazi-group to have a better target?
- draw_down 10y agoUm, don't you find the prospect of a Nazi group using it for that purpose significantly more trouble than people thinking that's why you did it?
- Nadya 10y agoNo. Because if the group cared enough they could make their own add-on to do just that. And it wouldn't need to go through Google to be installed for "members". "Is a member of a nazi-esque group" is not exclusive from "is tech literate enough to write browser add-ons". If you let others control your actions, even indirectly, you show them that they have power and control over you. Many tools that are beneficial are also "double-edged" and could be used for nefarious purposes. In most cases, they're better off existing than not.
- EGreg 10y agoI think that, in general, it comes down to opt-in vs opt-out. Facemash got the pics without opt-in. Facebook learned from that.
- bcg1 10y agoI think that your explanation would probably suffice to keep it from being banned. In the case highlighted in the article, the entire purpose of the program is to target people for harassment. They apparently didn't even pretend to have some other legitimate motive.
- timothya 10y agoContext is king.