4 ms·
Unlike the previous accident, which the Tesla S literally doesn't have the sensors to see the above-ground trailer... this Model X crashed into the side of a bu
by dragontamer 10y ago
Unlike the previous accident, which the Tesla S literally doesn't have the sensors to see the above-ground trailer... this Model X crashed into the side of a building. I'd like to assume that the below-chassis sensors would have been able to pick that up.
I'm more concerned about edge-cases like the Tesla S autonomous crash rather than cases like this one. My current assumption (pending evidence: we don't have any yet so we can only assume) is that the driver is the blame in this specific case.
We'll see when more data comes in.
----------
Unfortunately, I don't think it is moral for a car company to install sensors and use sensor data against the car's owner.
If I buy the car, then the whole car is allegedly mine: including these sensors that only Tesla can tap into. The fact that I don't have access to all the sensor data means that Tesla's definition of "ownership" is rather convoluted compared to a normal car.
- mikeash 10y agoThere's a "remote access" setting you can turn off. I believe that cuts off Tesla's access, not just your own. Of course, roughly nobody actually turns it off, because everybody prefers the convenience of having it on.
- dragontamer 10y ago> I believe that cuts off Tesla's access, not just your own So no way to cut off Tesla's access to YOUR OWN CAR, without cutting out your own access? And even then, you're not sure?
- mikeash 10y agoYeah, remote access goes through their servers. You can still drive the car, you just can't use their smartphone app. I don't know why you'd expect anything else. If you want to be sure, then pull the SIM card. It's a bit of work to get to it, but not too tough.
- dragontamer 10y ago> Yeah, remote access goes through their servers. You can still drive the car, you just can't use their smartphone app. I don't know why you'd expect anything else. Just because I open my computer up for OneDrive doesn't mean I am going to let Microsoft keylog all of my keyboard presses. Or Teamviewer (ignoring mistakes like hacks / software vulnerabilities). The closest analogue is Cortana / Swype reading keystrokes to train the keyboard AIs on phones, which is clearly denoted in the terms of use and can be turned off individually. Regardless, Tesla's policy and technology stack are designed to protect the company, not the customer. Lets put it this way, do customers get this Tesla black-box data available to them if they get into a mundane car crash on a normal road? To prove that it was the other driver's fault? Or does Tesla normally keep this data to itself?
- mikeash 10y agoI totally agree that it should be a separate control. But I'm not at all surprised that it isn't, and if you're so upset about this access that you consider it immoral, losing the smartphone app should be a small price to pay. I have no idea if we get this data in other circumstances. If I ever find out, I'll be sure to let people know. I hope I never have to find out, of course.
- dgacmu 10y agoSure it's moral - in fact, it's great. The question of morality only arises if there's asymmetric access to the data. In the event of a claim being made by the driver against the company, both sides should have complete access to the logs data to make their case more firmly. What shouldn't happen is ONLY one party being able to inspect the data. But this is unlikely to happen in practice. A lawyer for the driver would undoubtedly subpoena Tesla for access to the data. And a reasonable judge would probably concur. IANAL and IANAJ, so the latter is a guess. :)
- dragontamer 10y ago> But this is unlikely to happen in practice. A lawyer for the driver would undoubtedly subpoena Tesla for access to the data. And a reasonable judge would probably concur. IANAL and IANAJ, so the latter is a guess. :) So what's the process here? You're going to start suing Tesla so that you hope you can officially subpeona them of the data you don't have access to? Its asymmetric no matter what. The role of these logs should be reversed: the driver ought to have first-dibs at the logs to determine if he has a legitimate case to bring forth against Tesla. Then Tesla should subpeona the data once they start getting sued. In any case, Tesla holding the data so that they have the information-advantage against their own customers is a bit fishy.
- dgacmu 10y agoYes, that's exactly what you do when you sue anyone and you believe they have data relevant to the case. It's called discovery. First you have to have a reasonable basis for doing so, and a claim that their car auto-drove into the wall is such a basis.