3 ms·
Apple is a bad example; their secrecy means that humanity learns virtually nothing from most experiments. Most experiments fail -- either abject technical failu
by beambot 10y ago
Apple is a bad example; their secrecy means that humanity learns virtually nothing from most experiments. Most experiments fail -- either abject technical failures or merely commercially unviable at the time of their development. Hiding these away is a shame. People could learn from failures (not spending resources pursuing bad paths) or unviable explorations (revisit them later when conditions change).
I think a more useful example is Bell Labs and their Technical Journal. The journal involved a more-significant level of rigor without the PR and media hype.
Unfortunately, when the media follows every little happening (eg. patent publications)... big megacorps are left with two bad choices: let people draw erroneous, hyperbolic conclusions ("OMG! Ads in my eyes!") -or- address the PR and messaging directly head-on.
Publication may still be the solution, but the timing issues are acute. From a business perspective, you need to be filing IP as soon as you have reasonable evidence of a proof of concept. But by the time you have sufficient material for top-tier journal peer review, those patents are already being published. The solution might be (again) something like the Bell Labs Technical Journal... but that provides a lot of fodder for competitors and patent trolls. So it's a tough balance!
Either way... I applaud large organizations taking big technical risks and bets.
- bravo22 10y agoMy post was in response to: "I think the biggest problem here is that we have too much media coverage and scrutiny on stuff like this today". The coverage happens because Google talks about it; irrespective of merits of taking risks.
- beambot 10y agoYes... I know. And I'm saying that Google talks about it because patent publication forces their hand. They must either own it and talk about it themselves, or let people wildly speculate when patents are published.