8 ms·
A lot of the general notions about computing embodied in the iPad are revolutionary. The only question is whether Apple will succeed. Microsoft already trie
by stcredzero 17y ago
A lot of the general notions about computing embodied in the iPad are revolutionary. The only question is whether Apple will succeed. Microsoft already tried this same revolutionary move with tablet computing and failed. (Because they were trying to drag along Windows. I can see this as I Write this reply on a Windows slate PC.)
From the comments:
The idea of shackling an old business to a new business rings true in so many industries right now.
Watching media companies try to get the web to pay for operating a printing press, for example.
Apple is in danger of falling into this same trap as advancing tech enables form factors that change how people use computers. Their closed strategy could be a serious anchor as such new form factors blossom into a "Cambrian explosion" of unexpected new uses.
The difference between a Jailbroken iPhone and a shackled one is stark. (I can have say app in the background. I use this to make Google Voice calls over Skype on Bluetooth. My normal cell calls are 10¢ a minute Prepaid.) Someone smart could leverage a more open platform correctly and seriously wound Apple. Lucky for Apple, the telecoms are 10x more shackled than they. But that will only save them in the short term.
- Goronmon 17y agoA lot of the general notions about computing embodied in the iPad are revolutionary. Are they?
- jacquesm 17y ago> A lot of the general notions about computing embodied in the iPad are revolutionary. I've seen the ipad referred to as a large iphone that you can't make voice calls with, and I can't really fault that description. Which general notions about computing embodied in the ipad are the ones that you consider 'revolutionary' ? The fact that your jailbroken iphone can do a whole bunch of stuff the 'regular' issue ones can't is actually a strong point against apple being 'revolutionary' in this sense.
- stcredzero 17y agoYou totally missed the point I was trying to make. The iPad is the embodiment of the form factor revolution presaged by Alan Kay's Dynabook. It's simply one evolutionary step toward ubiquitous computing, of which the iPhone, Palm Pilot, 2nd tablet PCs were a part. I talk about the greater utility of my Jailbroken as a mark against Apple and the iPad. As more and more platforms combine the attributes required to compete with the iPad, its lack of openness will become more and more apparent. People want walled gardens. They just don't want it with a fascist homeowner's association. Or: they want scheduled maintenance with their car, but without the GPS data going to the dealer and a breathalyzer interlock as required equipment. Unfortunately, there are also those who don't mind the above.
- bad_user 17y ago> A lot of the general notions about computing embodied in the iPad are revolutionary Name 2.
- philwelch 17y agoMultitouch on a tablet scale and full abstraction of system operations (i.e. file and process management) from the user.
- jacquesm 17y ago> Multitouch on a tablet scale Like this ?: http://www.engadget.com/2009/02/10/dell-latitude-xt2-multi-touch-tablet-with-11-hour-battery-now-of/ http://www.engadget.com/2009/02/10/dell-latitude-xt2-multi-t... > full abstraction of system operations (i.e. file and process management) from the user. There have been plenty of attempts to do that in the past, the iphone does it as well. Revolutionary is to me something that will literally change the face of computing as we know it, the world wide web was revolutionary, the personal computer was revolutionary. The ipad is a nice gadget, it may be revolutionary but for that to be the case we will have to wait for the future to happen first, and it definitely isn't revolutionary in all possible futures. edit: Interestingly enough, I'd peg the ipad's chances at being 'revolutionary' a lot higher if apple decided to make it a completely open platform. Just like the web and the PC succeeded because in essence they were open. The fact that the iphone is closed and is a success makes you wonder how big a success it could have been if it were more open. I think that it might have been a lot bigger still. For some reason 'closed' is the new black and I really don't think that's the right direction, which probably shows from my feelings about all this. Of course Steve Jobs is in a much better position than I am to say that he's right, but I can't shake the feeling. btw, multi-touch has been around in one form or another since 1982...
- philwelch 17y ago"btw, multi-touch has been around in one form or another since 1982..." And almost no one is using it on a tablet scale yet. Nor has anyone (other than Apple) actually designed a tablet UI consistently around it yet, as opposed to trying to duct tape together a multitouch screen and a desktop UI. "> full abstraction of system operations (i.e. file and process management) from the user. There have been plenty of attempts to do that in the past" And when that approach ultimately succeeds for most users, it will be a combination of web apps and iPad-like clients. The iPad might be colossal failure overall, it might fail to catch on until it's cheap enough for the average user to have about three, or it might change the world next month--I'm not convinced any of these is true. "Just like the web and the PC succeeded because in essence they were open. The fact that the iphone is closed and is a success makes you wonder how big a success it could have been if it were more open. I think that it might have been a lot bigger still." If your hypothesis is true, Android is going to become an even bigger success than iPhone. Likewise, there's going to be an open (probably Linux) alternative to iPad, just as there's Android now and there were IBM-compatibles to compete with the Apple II and Mac proprietary hardware platforms. As it stands, Google's attempt at abstracting the system away is Chrome OS, which limits you exclusively to web apps. While that might be enough, it's hard to praise a design for "openness" when it doesn't let you run more than a web browser on your own machine. (Sure, you can install a different Linux on a Chrome OS netbook, but you can jailbreak iPhones and iPods touch as well--presumably iPads.) Edit: Can someone explain to me why I'm being downmodded here?