I think this is a case where the topic is something that enough people want to discuss so the post generates discussion regardless of the content. I agree with

I think this is a case where the topic is something that enough people want to discuss so the post generates discussion regardless of the content. I agree with the basic gist of your comment, there isn't much content here to discuss (no offense to the author, it doesn't seem like it was meant for a site like HN). Though I think you might be over-reacting a bit with the tone of your comment.