9 ms·
This quote seems very telling: > It used to be that only locals knew all the cut-through routes, but Google Maps and Waze are letting everyone know So they do
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
This quote seems very telling:
> It used to be that only locals knew all the cut-through routes, but Google Maps and Waze are letting everyone know
So they don't have a problem with people cutting through as long as they're "locals"; it's when the outgroup starts doing the same thing that people get up in arms.
If the through traffic is breaking traffic laws, that's a solvable problem. If the street has insufficient safety measures on it, that's also a solvable problem; see the comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11846812 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11846812 for an example of getting the road improved.
But if the problem is that the neighborhood street is actually a better route than the arterial roads and highways, then solve that problem; don't blame mapping software for noticing.
- mikeash 10y agoThat could just be about quantity, not groups. If only locals do it, that's a relatively small amount of traffic. If outsiders join in, that could be orders of magnitude more. I do agree with the overall point. If your local road is an attractive route and people use it to go places, don't blame the messenger. But it doesn't have to be about tribalism.
- drewcrawford 10y agoOf course it is necessarily about tribalism. If it were not we could just install an access gate that limits the throughput of the road to X cars per hour (without regard to whether you live on it or not) and consider the problem resolved. But a homeowner would oppose having an equal share with any other citizen for a road on which they live. Or, to see this the other way: consider a driver shrouded in a veil of ignorance, with the knowledge of what road he lives on and its traffic situation temporarily hidden from him. He sees a shortcut through a neighborhood that may be his, but it's statistically unlikely to be in his large city. He takes it.
- mikeash 10y agoYour access gate solution doesn't work because the impact on different drivers is dramatically unequal. If a cross-town commuter can't use that road then he might lose a minute or two of his time. If a resident can't use that road then he can't go home. Of course your hypothetical driver would choose to take the shortcut when shrouded from the knowledge that it's his road. It's a classic tragedy of the commons. Much of the purpose of traffic laws like these is to avert tragedies of the commons.
- DanBC 10y agoLocal people may know that children live and play there, and drive more cautiously. (I didn't downvote you.)
- Piskvorrr 10y agoWhereas to everyone else, the street looks and feels like a many-lane freeway, right? (No. It's just a convenient excuse; artificial stupidity, if you wish: "So I can't go max speed in here, Carmageddon-style? How am I supposed to know that an obviously residential street has residents? Traffic code? I barely know 'er!")
- JoshTriplett 10y agoYou shouldn't need tribal knowledge like that to drive safely and to keep others safe; the roads should be marked well for everyone, and all drivers should be cautious in all neighborhood settings.
- yardie 10y agoYou would think that but have you been driving lately? 20% are just assholes all the time. Not to far from me some guy ripped through a school zone at 60mph. This resulted in a fatality. Of course the family was on the news saying how a nice guy he was but what nice guy drives 60mph through a residential street. The driver died. He hit a schoolbus. Luckily, none of the kids were seated near the point of impact and none were critically injured.
- dagss 10y agoI would think the problem is the volume of traffic faced by pedestrians and neighbors, not specifically who drives. Many roads are simply suitable for moderate traffic. "Solving the problem" in this case often involves a roadblock in the middle so that you cannot drive through. Compared to changing Waze, this is "fair". But are you really happier then?
- Piskvorrr 10y agoUsually, yes. Car traffic flows like a liquid: anywhere it can, not where it ought to; the road is not blocked off to access - to cars, it just becomes two leaves instead of an edge, i.e. unroutable except for destination traffic.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> I would think the problem is the volume of traffic faced by pedestrians and neighbors, not specifically who drives. Possibly, but that wasn't the phrasing, and I suspect that wasn't the mindset. > Compared to changing Waze, this is "fair". But are you really happier then? Yes. Because if they apply to the local authority to get a road blocked for through traffic, that's the proper process to enact change at the right level.
- zo1 10y agoIn my part of the world, a lot of "quiet neighbourhoods" have put up boom gates at strategic entrances. Some are manned by security guards that open for you. In others, you have to swipe your hand over a sensor to make it open for you. It's used mostly for security, but no doubt it helps with keeping traffic-avoiding individuals from going through.
- astrodust 10y agoThere's a certain amount of irony here that people are complaining about cars clogging up their streets but think nothing of what they do when they're driving through other neighbourhoods, especially more urban ones. Suddenly they get a taste of why people living downtown are not too enthused about highways bringing in more people. A lot of this mess stems from the absurd designs of modern American subdivisions with their pointlessly twisty roads. A grid-based layout might mean more through traffic, but the traffic can filter through many, many different cross-routes rather than funnelling through the singular optimal route.
- pjlegato 10y agoGrids don't help much. Take a look at Google Maps' traffic report of Los Angeles' perfect grid layout during rush hour: the entire grid is usually solid red, almost every day. Like most other plans for ameliorating heavy traffic, it is somewhat effective for a short time, but it soon just causes that many more cars to try to drive through the area.
- JBReefer 10y agoThis is called "Induced Demand"
- gjolund 10y agoLA traffic defies reason. I've hit gridlock at 3am on the 101 before. The whole city feels like it was designed to be some elaborate torture device for commuters.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoIt was designed for a smaller number of single car drivers than it has today. And it was not designed for quick/cheap expansion. I guess any system of transportation would feel like torture for commuters if that system is overloaded and operating beyond its reasonable capacity.
- 10y ago
- pjlegato 10y agoI believe it's not an in- versus out-group issue as such. The issue is that the number of locals is a tiny fraction of the number of outsiders passing through, leading to a vast increase in traffic on the formerly quiet street. When only locals who lived on or near the street knew about the route, you might see five cars a day cutting through. Now that Waze is onto it, they're seeing five cars a minute cutting through.
- breischl 10y agoBut locals also know the area better, pretty much by definition. That usually makes them safer drivers. I know that the streets near my house are filled with kids because of the three schools nearby that use the park as a playground, that almost (not quite) every other intersection is a two-way stop instead of a four-way, and that even though the streets are wide the speed limit is 25. A flash mob of commuters is not going to have any of those advantages, and they'll be trying to route-find at the same time, so they are going to be less safe drivers. And they're probably going to be frustrated from dealing with traffic and going too fast on top of it. >>If the street has insufficient safety measures on it "Sufficient safety measures" is a function of the traffic load. eg, 2-way stops work fine with small volumes of traffic, but not at all for large volumes. Changing safety measures takes lots of time and some money - they cannot possibly react quickly enough to deal with flash mobs of commuters.
- throw7 10y agoIt's the opposite... knowing an area well usually makes dangerous drivers. Most accidents happen within some miles from home, mainly because one "knows" the area so well one lets their guard down.
- breischl 10y agoCertainly knowing an area can breed inattention, or risky behavior based on familiarity. My hunch is that it still works out to be safer on average, but admittedly I have no data for that. I was always under the impression that accidents happen close to home because that's where people spend most of their time so they get a lot more chances to have an accident there.
- superuser2 10y ago"Most accidents are close to home" is a Stat 101 Day 1 example of fallacious statistical reasoning. Hint: what do nearly all routes driven have in common?
- LanceH 10y ago
- nilkn 10y ago> So they don't have a problem with people cutting through as long as they're "locals"; it's when the outgroup starts doing the same thing that people get up in arms. That's one (particularly dramatic) way of looking at it. You could also interpret it to mean that it's just about the overall number of people making use of the routes. Adding in non-locals might just push that number over a certain threshold.
- birdmanjeremy 10y agoLocals only, brah. Go back to the marked detour you kook.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThe neighborhood street is only better because it is sized to serve the needs of the community round it. If everyone is making use of it then it's going to fail periodically, not unlike a small blood vessel in proximity to a blocked artery. Also, it's simply not possible at present to iterate the infrastructure the way it is to recalculate traffic timing; it's always going to be possible to arbitrage the traffic flow, so to speak.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]