5 ms·
If it's faster to take a neighborhood street than the interstate, there's a problem. It's not normal. It sounds like residents are at war with transportation
by paulddraper 10y ago
If it's faster to take a neighborhood street than the interstate, there's a problem.
It's not normal.
It sounds like residents are at war with transportation infrastructure instead.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jschwartzi 10y agoWelcome to rush hour in every major city.
- Piskvorrr 10y ago...in America (where cities are actually built for cars and people are just annoying, barely tolerated parasites).
- djrogers 10y agoOr London, or Paris, or Rome, or Shanghai, or Mexico City, or.... I'm sure there are shining paragons of traffic efficiency and urban design somewhere in the world, but you're not exactly doing a good ob of pointing them out here.
- Piskvorrr 10y agoLondon, Paris, Rome - all have a gasp workable public transport (can't speak for Shanghai or MC), dwarfing the vehicular traffic. Unless I had no option to choose at all, separated public transit beat the car traffic each and every time; even the delay of leaving the car at the outskirts and taking the train downtown is quicker than hopping along, a meter a minute (and then getting the privilege of hopping around blocks, trying to find a parking spot, with everyone else doing the same). Not the buses, of course; those get stuck in traffic like everyone else - but the trains get you wherever. Yes, I understand it's unfashionable, and you don't get a coffee cup holder or your own comfy chair for the whole trip ;) But it works. (Yes, there are other people on the metro. Well if you can't stand people, what are you doing in a city - which is a concentrated blob of people by definition?)
- omginternets 10y ago>London, Paris, Rome - all have a gasp workable public transport (can't speak for Shanghai or MC), dwarfing the vehicular traffic Yet they still have crippling rush-hour gridlocks.
- takno 10y agoThe approach in the UK is increasingly to regard the gridlock as an educational opportunity, whereby drivers learn to leave their cars at home and take public transport. combined with decent public transport investment, heavy road calming on non-main roads and progressive removal of parking spaces in town centres it's really having a very positive impact for everybody except the people who bizarrely still choose to sit in the gridlock.
- omginternets 10y agoFair enough, but that tells you that the solution is not "just provide public transportation". That was my point and, I suspect, the original commenter's point as well.
- serge2k 10y agoThis type of attitude is part of what drives people to take residential streets.
- takno 10y agowhile this clearly does happen, urban residential streets in the UK are usually much narrower and invariably reduced to a single lane by parked cars. They are also less often in a grid pattern which supports rat-runs, and most problem rat-runs have been identified and either blocked or traffic-calmed to death 20 years ago.
- blakeyrat 10y agoLondon and Paris have great subway systems, and yet somehow the streets above the subways are always gridlocked just as much as any American city I've seen.
- pekk 10y agoPeople are in those cars, just because you use a car doesn't mean you are not a person.
- Piskvorrr 10y agoOf course not. The problem is opposite: anyone not in car becomes an unperson, as only people in cars are worth considering.
- rlucas 10y agoFor the record, see Braess' paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox "Normal" and intuitive behavior is not what you can expect from a busy traffics system.
- mjevans 10y agoWhile this paradox might be a good theoretical tool for theory, I've disagreed that it is a good tool for modeling real situations since first hearing about it. * It is unrealistic that the mid-route would ever be created as described. * It is also unrealistic that the capacity of two parallel routes would also vary so much and have a mid-point where that reverses. * It would be much more realistic to have two routes, one of higher natural capacity, which react differently to increased load (not a static, no matter what, over-simplification). * Finally; it still does not address the issue of systems that are literally unable to cope with peek load; such as modern metro freeways in the US.
- rlucas 10y agoFor the record, see Braess' paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox "Normal" and intuitive behavior is not what you can expect from a busy traffics system.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoThere seems to be a new reality, a new problem with population growth and GDP fetishism: GDP rises with the number of people participating in the economy, true. But GDP and accompanying tax revenues don't rise enough. Infrastructure becomes overloaded and the government fails to expand capacity sufficiently. Tax revenues rise somewhat, but, again, not enough to pay for the necessary expansion. Traffic gets worse. One solution would be to literally force everyone to take high efficiency, high density modes of transportation (trains, public buses, carpools, chartered buses, etc) but local and even state governments don't seem to have the legal power (or will?) to do so. The gridlock continues.
- mmoche 10y agoEven if they had the power, or will, governments in ostensibly free nations shouldn't be forcing their population into a form of transport, just as they shouldn't be forcing their population into specific jobs, specific homes, or specific religions.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoI view it a bit differently. Trading freedom for efficiency sometimes makes sense. I have to admit that governments force us to do all kinds of things, and I accept that, mostly. For me the debate is about which things the government can mandate. If turning three out of four lanes on LA's stretch of the 405 freeway into HOV lanes meant that commute times from the Valley to Culver City became a reliable 20 minutes, I think I might be happier.
- Piskvorrr 10y agoIf wishes were horses, we'd all ride; in reality, such broad changes tend to have various side effects, which are often unpleasant enough to obliterate the intended positive effect.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoSure. But LA's increasingly frequent and widespread gridlock also has serious negative effects. Having government impose some new orderly process on a chaotic and inefficient transportation market (i.e. freeways) is not necessarily worse than the status quo. LA is grappling with a serious mess. It's affecting the business climate significantly. People can't reliably and predictably get to their place of work. The unpleasant side effects are already here.
- superuser2 10y ago10mph is blazingly, exceptionally fast for an interstate in a major city during commute hours. Building bigger highways sparks further-flung suburbs and the new traffic brings everyone else's commute times back to equilibrium.
- xenadu02 10y agoIndeed, you can see this in the Dallas area. The major roads have run out of room to expand and according to the old timers traffic is no better than it was in 1990. All the road expansion did was let people move to ever more distant suburbs.
- rplst8 10y agoYes, but eventually, if the roads are big enough, time itself is the deterrent to commuting a long distance. We've never gotten to that point since highway traffic never moves at speed during rush hour. The other driving factor would be wear and tear on the car - and the costs associated with maintaining a vehicle, but since Maryland doesn't have a yearly vehicle inspection, people are free to drive around on bald tires in a car with no brakes.
- Shebanator 10y agoIn the California Bay Area, this is not true. There is a non-trivial number of people who are willing to commute 2+ hours each way in order to live in bigger, cheaper houses in "safer" neighborhoods.
- rplst8 10y agoThe same is true of the Washington DC metro area... However, in both cases, I would bet that the distance involved is about 50-60 miles. If that traffic were moving at speed, it would be an hour commute - and I would submit very few people would put more than that amount of mileage on their car everyday (>30,000 miles/year).
- PaulHoule 10y agoThis has been the case in Los Angeles since the 1960s. The first time I went to L.A. we got in around 5pm on a Friday and planned to drive North on the 405 and get up to Venura or Santa Barbara before finding a hotel, which looks possible on a map. It is possible if you go at some other time, but definitely not possible on a typical Friday afternoon. We got caught in bumper-to-bumper traffic and pulled off at Santa Monica Boulevard and found a hotel which looked right out of Pulp Fiction. If you are going to most points north of LAX (to Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Hollywood, Burbank, etc.) a cabbie or Angelino will take you on surface streets because you get there way faster.
- djrogers 10y agoIn TFA, it was due to a construction project, and the problem largely abated once the construction cleared.
- wernercd 10y agoWell the story mentions roadwork starts, traffic increasing... roadwork ends, traffic stays increased as some drivers now use that route as matter of habit... I know I use a more varied bunch of routes thanks to Google Maps and Waze, some of which become preferred back-roads.