4 ms·
This article kind of sucks. > Gender inequality seems to have increased with early civilization, including agriculture. Why? The feminist explanation has been
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
This article kind of sucks.
> Gender inequality seems to have increased with early civilization, including agriculture. Why? The feminist explanation has been that the men banded together to create patriarchy. This is essentially a conspiracy theory, and there is little or no evidence that it is true. Some argue that the men erased it from the history books in order to safeguard their newly won power. Still, the lack of evidence should be worrisome, especially since this same kind of conspiracy would have had to happen over and over, in group after group, all over the world.
> Let me offer a different explanation. It’s not that the men pushed the women down. Rather, it’s just that the women’s sphere remained about where it was, while the men’s sphere, with its big and shallow social networks, slowly benefited from the progress of culture. By accumulating knowledge and improving the gains from division of labor, the men’s sphere gradually made progress.
Or maybe it's the more obvious answer that women were almost always stuck with the more mundane chores of child-rearing, cooking, and cleaning, and men were the ones doing just about everything else? I mean it's true that it wasn't really a conspiracy, it's entirely predictable that men would end up in that position, since they don't give birth or breastfeed, and they're physically stronger.
But at the same time, it wasn't that women just didn't choose to improve the things they worked on, it's that the things that fell to them lent themselves to relatively little social power or advancement. You can't gain more political power (individually, anyway) if you're just staying at home taking care of the kids, instead of, say, going on a military expedition.
- mulcahey 10y agoWhile some of his points are questionable, I think there are some good ones: > Today’s human population is descended from twice as many women as men… > For men, the outlook was radically different. If you go along with the crowd and play it safe, the odds are you won’t have children. Most men who ever lived did not have descendants who are alive today. Their lines were dead ends. Hence it was necessary to take chances, try new things, be creative, explore other possibilities. Sailing off into the unknown may be risky, and you might drown or be killed or whatever, but then again if you stay home you won’t reproduce anyway. We’re most descended from the type of men who made the risky voyage and managed to come back rich. In that case he would finally get a good chance to pass on his genes. We’re descended from men who took chances (and were lucky). > The huge difference in reproductive success very likely contributed to some personality differences, because different traits pointed the way to success. Women did best by minimizing risks, whereas the successful men were the ones who took chances. Ambition and competitive striving probably mattered more to male success (measured in offspring) than female. Creativity was probably more necessary, to help the individual man stand out in some way. I think that is a valid theory. Conjecturing that men have more natural audacity makes sense in modern society. It may contribute to an explanation of the gaps in workplace deaths, entrepreneurship, gambling, and men hurting themselves on JackAss and Tosh.0