3 ms·
Honestly, i've heard the anarchist argument plenty of times now, and the society being described never fails to seem like a state with the serial numbers filed
by krapp 10y ago
Honestly, i've heard the anarchist argument plenty of times now, and the society being described never fails to seem like a state with the serial numbers filed off to me.
It seems you've essentially described "laws" being interpreted by "courts" and enforced by "police." You're just calling the laws contracts, the courts contract courts and the police... hired mercenaries? Who is it forcing people to pay fines, or to exile themselves from society?
At scale it seems as if a marketplace of violence and a monopoly on violence look like the same thing to most particpants.
- zanny 10y agoThats kind of the point, isn't it? All the pros of states without the cons. It should look familiar.
- krapp 10y agoMy point is that, to me, you would still wind up the cons, the only difference being they would be governed by different incentives. A man with a gun is still a man with a gun, and a jail is still a jail.
- afarrell 10y agoGoing further, this is what society currently looks like in the US. There are a variety of organizations offering security and they have all entered agreements to cooperate, effectively forming a monopoly. Occasionally a new one arises (Dead Rabbits, Cosa Nostra, Latin Kings, etc), but it can only operate on the fringes and is ultimately muscled-out by the Federal Conglomerate.