2 ms·
What is so inflammatory about a claim that it would lead to polygamy? "Traditional" marriage definition is a reproductive (baring health issues) couple. If yo
by protomyth 17y ago
What is so inflammatory about a claim that it would lead to polygamy? "Traditional" marriage definition is a reproductive (baring health issues) couple. If you decide that isn't a consideration, then what difference does it make if you allow more than 2 people to be "married"? I am really struggling with trying to understand in the long term would lead to "chaos and anarchy".
I just wish the State would use another term and leave the term "marriage" to the churches. If some/any church wants to "bless" your social union as a marriage, then cool. I am kinda on the conservative side, but if someone else wants to have a "triple" union - I don't really care as long as it isn't some genetic travesty (siblings / cousins).
- dhume 17y ago"Traditional" marriage definition is a reproductive (baring health issues) couple IOW, it's not simply about reproduction. I'll reconsider taking that claim seriously when its proponents suggest that sterility should be a diqualification for marriage licenses (for extra credit, they can call for revoking marriage in cases where sterility sets in afterwards). Until then, I can only conclude that reproduction is an excuse to distract from their real reason.
- protomyth 17y agoShould I have said "historical"? I am not placing a value in that statement, I am just saying in something short of an essay how we got here. What exactly do you think the origin of marriage is or for that matter religions focus on marriage if not on reproduction (be fruitful and multiply)?
- dhume 17y agoI am not placing a value in that statement, I am just saying in something short of an essay how we got here. I recognize that what you posted was not necessarily your idea on the subject, hence "its proponents," rather than "you."
- Retric 17y agoMarriage in some form is probably well over 10,000 years old. Homosexual marriage is also probably just as old relatively speaking. The institution of marriage pre-dates reliable recorded history, and is part of Code of Hammurabi 1790 BC etc, so tracing its origins is basically impossible. Also, if you include animals that mate for life (some of which are homosexual bonds) it is probably millions of years old. The real issue IMO is how religious institutions portray history. When one of your sacred "Just So" stories portrays the creation of the institution of marriage it's easy to think of anything else as a perversion sacred law, even if such things are far older than your faith. EX: I once had someone defend their faith by saying “How else do you explain Adam’s missing rib?” That’s a world view so intermixed with their faith there is no way they can understand a secular viewpoint.