4 ms·
It's funny how other open source projects had no problem adopting ZFS or it's license. Not true; here's OpenBSD/OpenSSH developer Damien Miller on the CDDL:
by icebraining 10y ago
It's funny how other open source projects had no problem adopting ZFS or it's license.
Not true; here's OpenBSD/OpenSSH developer Damien Miller on the CDDL:
The CDDL is even more restrictive than the GPL and is
far more legally pernicious. In particular:
Clause 3.5 is a GPL-like "must distribute source" requirement.
Worse, clauses 3.3 and 9 have no place in a free software license.
I don't understand how anyone who has read the license could say that it
is even remotely "compliant with the BSD philosophy". The GPL is far
more acceptable than the CDDL.
> Is there a chance to have star integrated into OpenBSD?
Not with this license. If you want the BSDs to use star, then maybe you
should license it with a BSD license.
http://marc.info/?l=openbsd-tech&m=110806948606417&w=2 http://marc.info/?l=openbsd-tech&m=110806948606417&w=2
Here's Theo de Raadt:
And now, because of "ZFS and dtrace", we should throw that entire
Bostic-started effort out the window. Screw freedom, I need ZFS and
dtrace. (...)
Don't be fooled. In fact, I urge our users to investigate every
person who has mentioned "ZFS and dtrace" together in the past. Their
agenda is not the one that you or I believe in. Their agenda is
division.
http://openbsd-archive.7691.n7.nabble.com/CDDL-vs-GPL-and-maybe-some-implications-for-BSD-tp47760p47762.html http://openbsd-archive.7691.n7.nabble.com/CDDL-vs-GPL-and-ma...
- X86BSD 10y agoYeah so I'm not sure first of all quoting theo or openbsd folks is adding value to your argument. They are known to be quite, how should I say this, on the extreme side of things. And just because obsd holds this view that doesn't refute my statement. Illumos and FreeBSD are both OS and both are using it. So it is what it is.
- icebraining 10y agoIllumos didn't exactly "adopt" ZFS; it's a clone of Solaris created by core Solaris engineers, which just happened to live on beyond its original project. So essentially there's one project. Meanwhile, the GPL is used in FreeBSD, OpenBSD, MacOSX, Windows - and even SmartOS, an Illumos distribution.