6 ms·
> Why are people "already in the country" more deserving than those outside? In average, they aren't. But life isn't fair. You might as well ask why those that
by raverbashing 10y ago
> Why are people "already in the country" more deserving than those outside?
In average, they aren't. But life isn't fair.
You might as well ask why those that came are deserving of help and not others, and your ability to help before it gets detrimental to the collective.
> I propose helping the millions by not using violence to prevent them from performing labor for willing employers (an action which makes both them and the employer better off).
I don't disagree with this, and I'm sure several do that under the table already. But it seems some have a "rosier" idea of what you'll get http://www.ardmediathek.de/tv/Exakt/Falsche-Versprechen-locken-Fl%C3%BCchtlinge-a/MDR-Fernsehen/Video?bcastId=7545124&documentId=35277952 http://www.ardmediathek.de/tv/Exakt/Falsche-Versprechen-lock...
> If we have adequate law enforcement, isn't this a problem that will rapidly solve itself? The solution is simple: immigrant assaults a homosexual, has his possessions confiscated, goes do jail and is then permanently deported on exit.
If it worked like this I would be satisfied. But it's usually not so effective.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoIf you support unfair collective punishment and protectionism, why limit it to nationality-based groups? Why not restrict work opportunities for Black Americans also? And to protect "us" from the high rate of crime committed by Blacks, why not force them to live on the other side of town where they are less likely to harm "us"? (I put "us" in quotes, since I don't consider "us" to refer to any morally meaningful group.)
- raverbashing 10y agoGood. I suggest you go to your local animal shelter and adopt a cat. But then you'll be favouring one over the other. Even better, adopt all the cats they have there, lest you support unfair collective punishment.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoA better analogy would be that I adopt a cat and threaten people with violence for adopting the other cats. I didn't say an employer must hire all (or any) anyone. I just said that if a Canadian is willing to pay a Tamil to cook her food, we shouldn't threaten these people with violence to prevent them from engaging in this peaceful trade. In any case, taking as a given your previous premises (that unfair protectionism is ok based on statistical properties), you seem to have no rational problem with bringing back racial segregation?
- raverbashing 10y agoI think it's so funny that you're implying I'm racist, but I guess that's what happens when they are firmly rooted in their biased convictions I'll just add that as a note, Canadians are the worse case of "I'm not racist, but" that I've ever seen. Canadian immigration process is severely biased towards things like education level, criminal background and language knowledge. So unfair, right?!
- yummyfajitas 10y agoI'm not implying your racist. I suspect you aren't. I'm just pointing out that you don't seem to have a rational reason not to be - your reasoning supports racism just as well as nationalism. This simply means your position is unreasoned - merely a collection of arbitrary views held together by emotion, tribalism, mood affiliation and similar things. That's all. If you dispute this diagnosis, can you state a principled reason to oppose violence against blacks economically competing with whites, but support violence against Indians economically competing with Americans?
- raverbashing 10y agoYou're overthinking this. You can argue that the notion of country or state should not exist but that means of organization will happen regardless, with different levels of openness, because people is people and end up in groups. In the end, modern countries that were created because people have affinity with each other have lasted more than in the cases they haven't. Of course it's not rational, because people. And people in one groups will usually favour those in the same group (starting with the family) And in the IT world you'll probably find a lot of Indians that were selected in favour of native US blacks, because of what they know (and how much they charge to employ that knowledge, of course)