3 ms·
Looking at his preferred calculator, I really see no visual cues of what functions are supported. Is it a simple calculator or does it do complex formulas. Th
by protomyth 17y ago
Looking at his preferred calculator, I really see no visual cues of what functions are supported. Is it a simple calculator or does it do complex formulas. The normal OS X calculator acts like the physical object and gives the clues of a physical object. This is not to say I think the translation of a physical object is the best solution, but I really think that some better visual hints need to be given then just a blank document for new users.
The page turning Apple built seems to me the right way to go because it is simple gesture we grasp instinctively, the content is paged, and it looks good.
We can do so much better then physical objects on computers (look at the interface to many puzzle games), but it really needs to assist the new users and get out of the way of the old.
- Hexstream 17y ago"Looking at emacs, I really see no visual cues of what functions are supported..."
- arethuza 17y agoDon't you think that is a good thing?
- Hexstream 17y agoYes, it's a very good thing. Guys, I'm an emacs lover. I was just trying to nullify the argument against Soulver that the parent brought up by making an analogy to emacs which also has most of the functionnality hidden and yet is super great.
- silentbicycle 17y agoThat's because if there were any, the menus would wrap the Earth seven times. Seriously, though: To reflect such things visually, menus are typically used, and they bring limitations: they take up space (clutter), it's not always clear where the best places are for items (hierarchies are often ambiguous), deep menu trees mean you need several clicks to do things, etc. Textual interfaces have different trade-offs. They're less discoverable, for one thing, but they're also much easier to script, use rapidly (once you know them), etc. These trade-offs aren't always suitable, but for something that becomes a central part of your toolchain (like a calculator or text editor), it's often a net gain.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoVisual cues are distracting. They're training wheels. The ideal calculator has either a) so few functions that you can remember all of them trivially, or b) so many functions that it would be ludicrous to display them all (or to omit some). I can't think of any smart compromise in between. For example, let's say your calculator supports trig functions. Should it show you sine / cosine / tangent? Or all trig functions? Or should you dive into a "Trig" menu, so you're three clicks away from what you want to do, instead of being three keystrokes away? I've never had a reason to use trig functions in my desktop calculator. And yet, (sin (/ pi 2)) does exactly what I'd expect it to!
- protomyth 17y agosin (/ pi 2)) doesn't look the way it does in math books - it looks the way you have trained yourself programming to use it. Visual cues aren't distracting if done right, and I said that absolute replication of physical is not always the way to go. My objection is that a blank slate is probably not a good idea since it provides no help.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoRight. Once you're used to the format, it's really easy to image how other functions will behave.