2 ms·
I took Odersky's online course and used it for one project. It runs my home lighting system. My experience was definitely mixed. I liked the language for its
by wpietri 10y ago
I took Odersky's online course and used it for one project. It runs my home lighting system. My experience was definitely mixed.
I liked the language for its ambition. I think the notion that OO and functional approaches are complementary worked very well for me. There were a lot of interesting ideas in the language and the ecosystem.
However, there were a number of downsides. I came across a couple of bugs that were well known and apparently people were just expected to work around them. As others have said, compile times were terrible, and the tooling wasn't great. And at a one day Scala unconference one of the prominent Scala community members was a flaming asshole to me, which definitely didn't help.
What really put me off, though, was what Bruce Eckels described: "I’ve come to view Scala as a landscape of cliffs – you can start feeling pretty comfortable with the language and think that you have a reasonable grasp of it, then suddenly fall off a cliff that makes you realize that no, you still don’t get it." http://bruceeckel.github.io/2015/08/29/what-i-do/ http://bruceeckel.github.io/2015/08/29/what-i-do/
This was backed up for me by a talk by Paul Phillips, a major contributor to the Scala compiler: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jh94gowim0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jh94gowim0
So in the end, I'm likely to look elsewhere. The next language I'm trying out is Kotlin:
https://kotlinlang.org/ https://kotlinlang.org/
It's from the IntelliJ IDEA people, who I trust a great deal, and I just got done working through their nice in-browser IDE tutorial:
http://try.kotlinlang.org/ http://try.kotlinlang.org/
So far it seems to have all of the things I like about Scala plus a number of improvements. E.g., fast compile times were a clear goal, and I didn't come across anything that struck me as language astronautics.
- partisan 10y agoI had a similar experience. I took the Odersky course and thought it was love, but soon found myself uncomfortable with the cryptic syntax of the ancillary libraries and wondered whether I wanted to be comfortable with writing or reading inscrutable code. I am currently giving Kotlin a shot and so far I do like it. I downloaded and installed IntelliJ, then the kotlin-dropwizard github repo and imported it into IntelliJ with no problems. It runs well and the code is clean and legible.
- wpietri 10y agoYeah. I definitely had the same issue with the libraries. For me the point of a language is to reduce cognitive load to something manageable. It wasn't clear to me than any human is smart enough to use Scala well, but I fell over enough of Eckel's cliffs that I was pretty sure I was not a good match.