3 ms·
Wow, that was a lot to read. After reading all that, I wonder why Snowden didn't just take his own emails with him, too. He might have overlooked it. Yet, a car
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
Wow, that was a lot to read. After reading all that, I wonder why Snowden didn't just take his own emails with him, too. He might have overlooked it. Yet, a carbon copy or just stealth copy of any complaints to compliance groups or whatever might be worth remembering for future whistleblowers.
- riskable 10y agoHe probably couldn't without raising alarms. As administrator to the SharePoint site he had many means to access (and copy) the files contained therein (from the servers themselves) but to make a big copy of his emails would require very risky operations on his personal workstation. A device that is probably intricately monitored.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoYeah, the stuff was probably extremely hard: http://www.amazon.com/Cable-Matters-113051-Monitor-Splitter/dp/B005H3I38G http://www.amazon.com/Cable-Matters-113051-Monitor-Splitter/... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4dCIZAXceQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4dCIZAXceQ Really, difficult. ;)
- woodman 10y agoThe concern is a plausible cover for action. Your suggested solution would be a little difficult to explain away - especially considering the kind of coworkers you'd have at the NSA. Instead of explaining why you're archiving all your mail, you'd have to explain the cabling, capture card, massive video files...
- nickpsecurity 10y agoHe connected on monitored systems to all kinds of servers under several credentials to steal their files. You think a hidden camera on his chest aimed at his monitor or phone just angled in its direction is too much risk, though?
- woodman 10y agoYes. There are a lot of rational explanations for why you'd break security protocols, there is no good reason to come into work wearing a wire. Would you rather have to explain a login to IT security, or explain the pinhole camera taped to your chest - after a newly instituted random wanding takes place?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThere is not a single, rationale reason why one guy would be mass downloading files under several people's names on his personal machine. Whereas, wearing a wire long enough to look at a few emails entails almost no risk in comparison. There will be nobody noticing it unless you're very careless. You will also leave no records. There's about no comparison between screenshoting some emails and conning employees out of passwords then mass downloading TS files. My suggestion is WAY lower risk. Worked for CIA and KGB whole Cold War, goo. ;)
- woodman 10y agoI know that you have a good grasp on security, not only is it in your name - but we've discussed the issue before... so the position you're taking on this is surprising. You've never seen an employee blatantly violate security policies in order to meet a deadline, or just because they're way out of their depth? He was writing a unit test that ran in a production environment, there - stupid reason that gets you fired but doesn't result in the FBI landing on you like a ton of bricks. This is kind of a silly discussion though, Snowden was in a very good position to be aware of the risks for his selected course of action. Cover for action is a tradecraft phrase - the CIA and KGB recognize the importance of running an op on more that wishful thinking and luck. The only reason why miniature cameras are associated with them is because of embarrassing public failures, not because that is their MO.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI just said in another comment he could've done it in many ways that don't involve a camera. It's one among many. Overall point is he was moving massive, unauthorized data from his computer to HD's or something. He could've moved some emails, too. If not due to security, he could sneak photos of a handful of emails. Cover or not given he was about to crash and burn his whole life. He could save them for last.
- gherkin0 10y agoYeah, I'm sure he would've raised no suspicions whatsoever by taking snapshots of his NSA workstation screen with a camera. /s
- nickpsecurity 10y agoHe wouldn't have if he did it right. Security was very lax if you've followed anything about the situation. Whereas, I've done exactly this in a higher security setting. I'm not speculating. He can bug his computer. He can hide executables tgat copy it to disks. He can screenshot it to disks. He can photo/video the screen. Examples abound. And remember he's a trained, ex-CIA spy. Not some idiot that cant pull off fieldcraft 101. He just failed to collect evidence one way or another for a key claim.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoI was thinking the same thing. Perhaps he does have a copy, and is letting the NSA prove to the world that it will lie if it thinks it can get away with it before releasing them.