3 ms·
I don't think it is written in stone that you must have a job to receive a negative income tax. That would be one way to implement it, but you could also have a
by maxerickson 10y ago
I don't think it is written in stone that you must have a job to receive a negative income tax. That would be one way to implement it, but you could also have an implementation that was based on some arbitrary level of income, where if you didn't reach that income, the government gave you the difference, even if it were the full amount (this would be a bad way to do it, but nonetheless). For sure, a negative income tax that required employment would not be a UBI. So they may overlap is a better statement than saying it falls under the umbrella.
It's also the case that a UBI is only pretend universal. There are people that will see either an increase in their effective tax rate or a decrease in their buying power (the latter if you fund it by printing money).