9 ms·
Cloud.gov
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- homero 10y agoI'd love to use them. Going to the source will reduce latency because the mitm is removed. Now it's just the man. Seriously, I'd switch from DO.
- verst 10y agoYou can certainly host it yourself on AWS, GCP, Azure etc. The general services administration is restricted to only assist federal government agencies, so you wouldn't be able to use the version being managed for the federal government.
- bmogilefsky 10y agoAre you positive about that? :) https://books.google.com/books?id=bWI7AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA10&lpg=PA10&dq=105-50.000+gsa&source=bl&ots=h1zlSWQRZb&sig=noMZZDZNiY3iZZwcD21v1xbTy58&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi7of7dhPHKAhXFWz4KHdsiDOgQ6AEIKTAC#v=onepage&q=105-50.000%20gsa&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=bWI7AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA10&lpg=P...
- verst 10y ago:) I remember having that discussion with you in person. You'd definitely know it better.
- jacques_chester 10y agoIf you want a hosted Cloud Foundry, my employers run one in Pivotal Web Services[0], aka PWS, aka p-dubs. IBM BlueMix includes a CF instance. There's also AppFog and AnyNines. Naturally, I think ours is the best. It's usually the most up-to-date, based on the internal monitoring I've seen. We upgrade PWS to the latest Cloud Foundry release usually within a week of one being tagged. My favourite part about it is that thanks to BOSH, basically nobody ever notices that we upgraded the entire platform underneath them. [0] http://run.pivotal.io/ http://run.pivotal.io/
- verst 10y agoI'm about to join 18F (in a few weeks), working on cloud.gov. I worked on the Google Cloud Platform team around the time Compute Engine and Big Query were launched (but spent most of my time on App Engine). A few weeks ago at the Cloud Foundry Summit the folks from cloud.gov.au gave a keynote. Cloud.gov got some nice shoutouts - the Australian counterparts reused a lot of the cloud.gov work, thanks to the transparent open-source approach. Listing of cloud.gov related Github repos: https://docs.cloud.gov/ops/repos/ https://docs.cloud.gov/ops/repos/
- rememberlenny 10y agoAwesome!! Looking forward to meeting you!
- Veratyr 10y ago> Australian counterparts Could you elaborate? I'm an Australian but I haven't heard about anything 18F/Cloud.gov-like back home.
- auxesis 10y agohttps://www.dto.gov.au/our-work/cloud/ https://www.dto.gov.au/our-work/cloud/
- fiatjaf 10y agoProfessional criminal deployment for thieves and assassins.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoPlease don't do this here.
- darawk 10y agoThis is really cool. 18F has been doing a lot of amazing work, it seems like the possibility of government tech not totally sucking may be on the (somewhat distant) horizon.
- wslack 10y ago:) Thanks! I also work at 18F, but not directly on cloud.gov. Govtech is a huge market, and I wouldn't expect any individual effort to turn the entire ship. Hopefully, though, we can provide a space to experiment and build with modern solutions and practices to make them more "normal." I'm especially a fan of developing in the open - you can see our commits and issue discussions and keep track of how we're doing as your civil servants. The other thing I love is that all of our work is in the public domain or CC0.
- walrus01 10y agobutt.gov ?
- verst 10y agoCare to elaborate your disapproval?
- bmogilefsky 10y agoGoogle for "cloud to butt extension"
- verst 10y agoHa! I figured it was something like that. So a statement concerning the jargon...
- cloudjacker 10y agoat first I was going to make fun of them for choosing "Cloud" half a decade after that buzz word reached its peak, but then I looked at the service and it is pretty cool
- frozenport 10y agoIsn't the the "Platform-as-a-service" logo the Amazon AWS logo? https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/1d/AmazonWebservices_Logo.svg/2000px-AmazonWebservices_Logo.svg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/1d/Am...
- Godel_unicode 10y agoLook the domain up in domaintools, they run on top of AWS govcloud. https://whois.domaintools.com/cloud.gov https://whois.domaintools.com/cloud.gov
- frozenport 10y agoI wonder if they are just reselling: https://aws.amazon.com/govcloud-us/ https://aws.amazon.com/govcloud-us/
- verst 10y agoCloud.gov is a PaaS based on Cloud Foundry. The idea is that it can run on pretty much any IaaS provider (as long as the Cloud Foundry plugins are written), certainly not limited to AWS.
- bmogilefsky 10y agoWe are using AWS GovCloud for our base IaaS layer, but we run a PaaS layer on top based on Cloud Foundry... That's the actual cloud.gov service being provided, the location on AWS GovCloud is just an implementation detail.
- bmogilefsky 10y agoI'm the product lead on cloud.gov... Thanks for noticing us! There are other Cloud Foundry deployments, but what makes cloud.gov special is the focus on ensuring federal agencies are actually able to use it. Federal compliance for a cloud service provider is a tough bar to clear, and without it most agencies are simply unable to take advantage of capabilities the rest of the world now takes for granted. That in turn impedes improvements in the many services the government has to offer. We've just reached the "FedRAMP Ready" status, which is a signifier of confidence that cloud.gov will make it through the exhaustive auditing process to come. Best of all, everything were doing is open source, including all the compliance work, so others will be able to follow in our footsteps. AMA!
- mcritz 10y agoAny plans to standardize agencies tech stacks? Is that even a good idea?
- bmogilefsky 10y agoWe can't control the decisions they make, and wouldn't want to... Each agency has their own CIO, and needs to be able to make decisions about stacks based their needs. Compliance requirements for running a service in public are so huge that agencies have conservatively stuck to ancient options, or farmed it all out to vendors. Our goal is to make the operations, deployment, and compliance aspects of service delivery trivial so they can put more of their resources (and those of the vendors they pay) into the improvement of the services they provide rather than sinking a huge portion of their budgets into redundantly addressing compliance and deployment concerns. And of course, use modern tech.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoGood luck with that. I was only a government contractor and the amount of blue badges that argue how the other agency is doing it wrong / stupid and they would never use their stack is insane.
- wslack 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 10y agoI'm the product lead on butt.gov... Thanks for noticing us! There are other butt Foundry deployments, but what makes butt.gov special is the focus on ensuring federal agencies are actually able to use it. Federal compliance for a butt service provider is a tough bar to clear, and without it most agencies are simply unable to take advantage of capabilities the rest of the world now takes for granted. That in turn impedes improvements in the many services the government has to offer. We've just reached the "FedRAMP Ready" status, which is a signifier of confidence that butt.gov will make it through the exhaustive auditing process to come. Best of all, everything were doing is open source, including all the compliance work, so others will be able to follow in our footsteps. AMA!
- bmogilefsky 10y agoI LOL'd... I had the same extension installed, but had to uninstall it when I saw the word constantly as part of my job.
- walrus01 10y agomove your mission critical data to my butt!
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11838077 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11838077 and marked it off-topic.
- nvas 10y agoI work in GSA as well, and I have a lot of trouble getting software approved that you use all the time, even getting nginx approved took a long time. Forget about vagrant, virtual box, recent versions of python, etc... How were you able to get ATOs to operate most of your systems and work through these policies?
- konklone 10y agoThis is actually a great time to talk about this stuff, but maybe easier on email (firstname.lastname@gsa.gov) than HN. Drop me a line!
- nvas 10y agoLol, why don't we discuss it in the open?
- konklone 10y agoSure, we have a lot of ATO/compliance stuff in the open: https://pages.18f.gov/before-you-ship/ https://pages.18f.gov/before-you-ship/ And there's a GitHub repo with an issue tracker that would make for better conversation capturing than HN: https://github.com/18f/before-you-ship https://github.com/18f/before-you-ship
- nvas 10y agoDon't get me wrong, I really like the stuff you guys are doing, but I think 18F and the rest of the Gov operate in two different realms of bureaucracy and feasibility. Your management is on board with this stuff, while for the rest of the Devs in the government it's an uphill battle from the bottom. There is still a large gap between software that is on the approved list and the stuff you use, but as I am sure we both know, there are waivers and blind eyes for that. If someone really wants it, it will happen. You guys are paving the way with your tools and process. But, please be careful, one serious security breach and it's kaput. For example; the incident with slack. I know it was trivial and people chose to blow it out of proportion, but regardless, it will now be harder for me to get slack approved for our team.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- scalio 10y agoWhat is such a fabulous cloud made of? Broccoli? Or maybe still only a datacenter?
- sean99 10y agoIN NEED OF PROFESSIONAL HACKERS? contact us on {masterminditservices@gmail.com}. or +1(205) 900-9736 Below is a list of some of some services we offer Mobile Hacking, email, Social Media Hack, School grades changing, Clearing of criminal records, Password sniffing, Bank Transfers and Company Money-Wire services, Cyber Security, Computer Security, SMTP Any domain, Cpanel, Unlimited, Shell, RDP, Leads, Cpanel, fulls, EIN, Pin, W2, SSN, DOB, fulls for Loans, Mystery shopper, Assistant BOS, Any Country Leads, Location detecting, SQL DB penetration, Penetration testing, Software testing, Database Penetration, Website Ransoming etc
- rambos 10y agoAs someone who develops for a Gov't agency, this is the wrong move. So much money has been spent on mimicking the private sector innovators. Millions and millions of tax dollars spent on these type of projects. The focus really needs to be on building a process to better integrate private cloud services and gov't applications. I mean they already are for the most part: https://aws.amazon.com/compliance/fedramp/ https://aws.amazon.com/compliance/fedramp/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/TrustCenter/Compliance/FedRAMP https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/TrustCenter/Compliance/FedRA... http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20160229005262/en/ServiceNow-Gains-FedRAMP-Certification-U.S.-Government http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20160229005262/en/Serv... Seriously this is just another wasteful program. The Gov't and 18F will hype it up, but don't be fooled.
- jacques_chester 10y ago> So much money has been spent on mimicking the private sector innovators. They're using open source Cloud Foundry, literally to avoid spending millions of dollars mimicking the private sector innovators.
- bmogilefsky 10y agoYou listed two IaaS provider and one SaaS provider. cloud.gov is a PaaS provider. There is no FedRAMP PaaS available to agencies, and PaaS is the level of abstraction needed to accelerate delivery of services the government itself provides. We also leverage the fact that AWS GovCloud already has FedRAMP status as an IaaS to accelerate our delivery of cloud.gov (which sits on top of it), so we're piggy-backing on the money and effort already spent and eliminating the millions we would otherwise spend by having the government run the IaaS layer. In other words... > The focus really needs to be on building a process to better integrate private cloud services and gov't applications. ...that's what we're doing!
- ddelmoli 10y agoActually, there are several FedRAMP PaaS' available to agencies. A quick look at https://www.fedramp.gov/marketplace/compliant-systems/ https://www.fedramp.gov/marketplace/compliant-systems/ lists several compliant PaaS offerings, including one (Autonomic Resources LLC – ARCWRX) based on OpenShift. It's great to see activity in this space.
- tfg4k 10y agoI apologize but browsing first thing in the morning, was I the only one who assumed this was a joke?
- herbst 10y agoYou are not alone. I Still question how much of a good idea that is. It certainly makes it self a popular target for attacks by default.
- cadou191 10y agoFor University Grades changing +Erase Criminal Records hack +Driver License +Facebook hack, Twitter hack, Instagram hack, Gmail, Yahoo hack +Already hacked Paypal, MasterCard, Credit Card untraceable balance +Email interception get a hold of consultanthackers@outlook.com , certified , professional and highly time conscious... call (302) 365-0294 and its done !
- zabador 10y agoThis is the only government website I have seen that does not look like it was designed in the 90's. It is pleasant to look at.
- knomoslaw 10y agoHi Bret, long time fan-first time commenter! In the govFresh excerpt that led me here you state the 'Federal compliance for a cloud service provider is a tough bar to clear'. Have you discovered the data policy map is in line with US corporate standards (e.g. Microsoft data security) or separate and distinct? I'd like to understand to what degree.gov innovation into the cloud is at parity with existing, more public facing standards or rewriting what we know and observe today. Haven't read every comment but a quick ctrl+f didn't find any keywords on the topic;) thanks for the insight! Jesse@knomos.law