6 ms·
Interactive Salary/Equity Chart for Jobs Offered in the San Francisco Bay Area
- jacalata 10y agoInteresting data - what do the colors mean on the chart?
- minimaxir 10y agoThey're just a visual aid to list the change in salary. It works well with the background of the hover tooltip.
- misnamed 10y agoLower range for engineers than I would have expected.
- hox 10y agoThis is just from angel list. So essentially just early stage startup salary ranges, presumably?
- jonathankoren 10y agoAngel List's salaries are literally a joke. It's not hard to find something like "senior full stack developer; salary: $1,000 equity 0.0%" or "co-founder salary $0, equity 0.0 - 0.05%" It's completely useless. I can't imagine who you'd actually attract with these ads, because you literally can't pay the rent with this money and the equity for senior positions is insulting.
- minimaxir 10y agoWhat I wanted to do was map offers to startups (so I could at the least tag smaller startups), but the AngelList API intentionaly omits the startup name/information from the Jobs endpoint. I'm annoyed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bduerst 10y agoI was going to say, why not scrape their pages? But they seem to require you to log in to view any job postings, and even then it's some custom feed.
- ddebernardy 10y agoThis is based on angel.co data, so it's woefully lowballed.
- tcoder 10y agoExtreme sampling bias. Startup has opening -> Can't fill it with people in their network -> Can't fill it with people who come to them -> Resorts to Angel List posting -> Angel list posting stays online longer because they have trouble filling it -> high turnover means the job ad stays up forever or keeps getting reposted. Great jobs tend to skew toward the left side of that funnel = sampling bias.
- bduerst 10y agoPretty much. Another major assumption here is that Angel List postings are legitimate - even though some companies post "job openings" online to vacuum up resumes for a database.
- superuser2 10y agoTheir career-wide median is just barely north of what I was offered coming off a college internship, with no competing offers or negotiation.
- dclowd9901 10y agoSame. I would've guessed mid 100s for engies, easily. Probably closer to high 100s
- diziet 10y agoI would cut out all the data with equity above 2% as the signal there is probably very noisy.
- williesleg 10y agoSo funny all the big idea, big cloud companies are just making more slaves build their empires. Everyone profits except the workers.
- swordswinger12 10y agoNice charts, this is really cool. One thing, though - it's weird to have "researchers" not compared against engineers, since at lots of places they're functionally just two different titles for the same job. Is there a reason for that choice?
- Swizec 10y agoWhy is there never a chart on HN that makes me feel like I'm paid fairly? Surely that's some sort of HN bias ...
- skj 10y agoDare I ask whether the charts make you feel over paid or under paid?
- Swizec 10y agoUnder paid. Always.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Impossible 10y agoHah, HN gives me the same feeling pretty consistently. If/when I leave the game industry I'll be disappointed if I have less than $500K total comp as a result of years of reading HN comments on what decent engineers should get paid.
- shinymark 10y agoI love this comment. I've been running my own small game studio for nearly five years in San Francisco and this resonates deeply. After reading HN for a while I constantly question my life choices work-wise.
- mahyarm 10y agoWell don't feel too bad, we also pay $2000-5000/month for 2 bedroom apartments.[1] California also has a tax rate at the same level as Canada. Being a digital nomad you can keep the tax rate and cost of living pretty low. But typical bigco sr. eng total compensation is around $250k. On top of that JS engineers tend to get paid less than mobile or backend engineers, but business owners make the most out of all of them. [1] Depending how long you want to commute to work and where work is.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoPathetic amount of equity, 0.1/0.02%. Startups should be ashamed. Your greed, your loss.
- bagels 10y agoIf you have, say, 200 employees, how much equity do you suggest offering?
- wscott 10y agoOf course, they should get 10% each. Don't be a greedy bastard.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoThese are angelList companies so the safe assumption is there is significant less than 200 employees. How many 200 person startups are their relative to 1-10 person startups, 1 out of 100 or more. Salary is low too so safe assumption.
- smaili 10y agoI think it's inportant to point out the source of data is Angel List and therefore the numbers predominantly reflect those of startups.
- benkuykendall 10y agoThere are plenty of engineering jobs in the "non-engineering" graph. ("Fullstack Javascript Ninja" 3% 50K) ("Avionic Software Lead" 6.25% 120k) ("Software [Developer]" 3.5% 32.5k) This seems like it invalidates the results.
- minimaxir 10y ago3 jobs out of 3,000 in a category does not invalidate the results and is within acceptable error (and even if there was a super-mega-ultra outlier as a result, that's why the median is used instead of the average). Although I made my best effort, it's infeasible for anyone to get 100% perfect categorization, which is why I would not have made this visualization without having a sufficiently large sample size.
- benkuykendall 10y agoI agree that a few misclassifications is not a huge problem, but it suggests a bigger methodological flaw. Looking at your source code, it seems your definition of engineer is grepl("engineer", tolower(job_title)) | grepl("developer", tolower(job_title) This seems like a poor definition of engineer to use. It includes "VP Engineering" but excludes "CTO", it includes "Growth Engineers" (marketers) but excludes "Code Ninjas" (developers). Short of word2vec, I don't think you're going to be able to automatically classify people as engineers based on job title.
- minimaxir 10y agoThat heuristic is good for 99%+ of the data set (and probably higher accuracy than a word2vec approach anyways). That's more than acceptable for this analysis.
- jonathankoren 10y agoYou don't even need word2vec good old cosine sim or an svm on the descriptions would classify theses. But if you're stuck with just the titles, just make some more patterns. There's not much you can do without building a simple dictionary.
- powera 10y agoEquity percentage graphs of a large number of companies, with no additional information, are completely useless information. I'd much rather have 0.01% of Google than 1% of whatever your startup is.
- wolframarnold 10y agoI'd be curious if the distribution of salary data from H1-B filings was more or less the same. Anecdotally for brand name companies, eg Netflix, the selection bias of Angel List data to the lower end seems to be confirmed. The database publicly searchable and I had seen a visualization once but can't find the link. http://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=NETFLIX+INC&job=SENIOR+SOFTWARE+ENGINEER&city=&year=2015 http://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=NETFLIX+INC&job=SENIOR+SOFT...
- NullCharacter 10y agoI'll weigh in; work (remotely) for a startup in the Bay Area, around 100k salary with .5% equity. I'm hoping to have more equity granted to me in the form of options in the coming months as the company turns a profit. Otherwise, life is good.
- passiveincomelg 10y agoMaybe the ranges are more useful in the Bay Area. For Berlin I saw some companies putting €30k - €100k because it's required on Angel List.