3 ms·
I had two Honeywell Smart thermostats get fried by power surges. Because the design of these 'smart' thermostats is just stupid. It's wrong for any of these th
by cmrdporcupine 10y ago
I had two Honeywell Smart thermostats get fried by power surges. Because the design of these 'smart' thermostats is just stupid.
It's wrong for any of these thermostats to be using these wires for power. That is not the purpose of those wires. For that matter, it's shit engineering to require the thermostat be mounted on the wall hooked up to those wires like your old thermostat. The purpose of those wires, with their 24V AC, is to toggle relays. They could just as easily be done directly _at the furnace_, or just have a low-power battery powered radio module on the relay wires, with a WiFi or other wireless receptor talking to your sensors elsewhere, and with an app on your phone or tablet to control it.
Nest is an absolutely terrible design that everyone else copied. Its terrible design is crap for installation, customer support, and maintenance. It's needlessly complex.
But it looks nice?
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoWhat relay does a C wire toggle? From what I've read its only purpose is to provide a continuous stream of power. There's nothing in the spec that forbids using the R and C wires for power, in fact that is their stated purpose. Now, these bypass kits or similar, are a little hacky. But you're talking about the C wire itself being so, which just isn't the case. IF you have one available that is exactly what it is design to do. But, yes, I'd prefer USB at the thermostat.