3 ms·
A computer generated check is absolutely as valid as a paper check from your checkbook. I routinely generate images of checks which I then snap a picture of rig
by zaroth 10y ago
A computer generated check is absolutely as valid as a paper check from your checkbook. I routinely generate images of checks which I then snap a picture of right off the monitor in order to remote deposit. Of course this is always done with the written and signed consent of the account holder.
Since you can't ACH outside of the US (I think) and any bank in the US has pretty strict "Know Your Customer" requirements, you will know for sure at least the first hop of where the money went.
I've heard of "work from home" schemes to include people acting as a middle-man for funds like this. They receive the ACH funds, and then they wire them overseas or send them via Western Union. These people, whether they were honestly duped or not, have committed a felony.
So when people worry about checks containing all the data you need for someone to empty your account, the first thing to consider is deterrence is very strong in this area because the penalty is massive, and tracking where the money was sent via ACH is easy.
That said, it would be nice if they could phase in a new standard which used one-time codes and provided real-time validation for this sort of thing. ACH transfer fees are extremely low compared to credit cards after all.
- patmcc 10y ago>>>I routinely generate images of checks which I then snap a picture of right off the monitor in order to remote deposit. Of course this is always done with the written and signed consent of the account holder. This is clever on your part, but holy cow there should be a better system than this.
- cperciva 10y agoyou can't ACH outside of the US (I think) Sort of. There are "International ACH Transfers", but they're not exactly like domestic ACH transfers; I believe they need extra AML information added, for one thing. Being able to make domestic ACH transfers does not imply being able to make international ACH transfers.
- sievebrain 10y agoRelying entirely on KYC to identify abusers is very fragile. Not only does the USA not have a modern banking system but it also lacks robust ID verification procedures.
- driverdan 10y agoAs far as I know bank tellers / officers receive no ID document training. Bouncers are better at detecting fraudulent documents.