3 ms·
I feel bad about bashing a YC company -- even though I'm not part of YC, I feel that I've been on news.YC for long enough to be at least somewhat part of the YC
by cperciva 17y ago
I feel bad about bashing a YC company -- even though I'm not part of YC, I feel that I've been on news.YC for long enough to be at least somewhat part of the YC community -- but seriously, this is your idea of security? I'm sure you can do better.
- pvg 17y agoDon't. The only thing I'd suggest is the disclaimer "I'm just the author of a competing service -- Tarsnap. [...]" belongs at the top. It doesn't invalidate your points but if there's any reason to perceive a conflict of interest, the sensible thing is to get it out of the way first, rather than as an aside at the end.
- paraschopra 17y agoYup, honestly, the post is really good but the plug at the end gave a linkbait flavor to the whole thing.
- DougBTX 17y agoMy reaction was, "Oh, this is cperciva's blog, that man knows his stuff."
- constantinople 17y agoAgreed but few things are most distasteful than technological catfighting.
- jhancock 17y agoI don't see this as a cat fight. People using online backup services are being sold "security". Not all users care about, much less understand, security to the extent that user of tarsnap do, but users should know if a product's marketing matches the reality of the product. It is common in most industries for a competitor to point out these gaps. Colin provided a tasteful opposing argument to ZumoDrive's marketing, IMO.
- nailer 17y agoAlso a lot of other cloud storage providers encrypt the data so only their clients have access to it: Nasuni does this too.
- rythie 17y agoAgreed. I feel the author conned me while reading it, when all the while it was a pitch for his own product.
- cperciva 17y agoI wasn't sure whether to put that at the top -- one the one hand it would solve the problem you describe, but on the other hand, most of the readers of my blog already know about Tarsnap and it rather interferes with the "flow" of my text. But judging by the comments here, it sounds like I came to the wrong conclusion -- I'll edit that post to state my conflict at the top.