4 ms·
"CSID, an identity monitoring firm that is in the midst of being acquired by credit bureau giant Experian." Experian a few months ago had a breach whereby mill
by bogomipz 10y ago
"CSID, an identity monitoring firm that is in the midst of being acquired by credit bureau giant Experian."
Experian a few months ago had a breach whereby millions of T mobile customers who had no idea that Experian was storing their data, had all of their sensitive data stolen. Experian's "solution" to the problem was to offer those who had their data stolen 2 years of free credit monitoring. Think about that for a moment - "we allowed your sensitive data that you didn't approve of us storing to be compromised and so we will now offer you a 2 year service after which you will be charged."
That is so completely outrageous, people should be out with pitchforks and torches but you can't fight this stuff, these agencies are far too powerful.
Just to further underscore how outrageous Experian and the other two agencies are - Experian notified people who had their data compromised using snail mail! What kind of decision is that for a time-sensitive situation?!
Lastly the letter they sent to customers and I read my friend who was a victims letter, said that the data that was compromised was data they were storing on T Mobile's behalf, as if they were in no way culpable.
So I guess I this is their strategy going forward is to acquire a half-baked and suspect security firm that will damage innocent companies reputations the same way they themselves have damaged innocent people's credit and identities.
I would urge people to call the three big credit agencies - Trans Union, Experian and Equifax and request that your credit be "locked." This means that nobody can look at your credit profile, except for people you currently have a line of credit with. You will be issued a pin and if and when you need to apply for credit you can then unlock your credit profile and re0lock it afterward. You need to re-up on this every two years which is insane as having your credit profile locked should be the default and should be in perpetuity, but you do what you can.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> I would urge people to call the three big credit agencies - Trans Union, Experian and Equifax and request that your credit be "locked." This means that nobody can look at your credit profile, except for people you currently have a line of credit with. You will be issued a pin and if and when you need to apply for credit you can then unlock your credit profile and re0lock it afterward. You need to re-up on this every two years which is insane as having your credit profile locked should be the default and should be in perpetuity, but you do what you can. Keep in mind you will be charged for this. https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0497-credit-freeze-faqs https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0497-credit-freeze-faq... > You'll need to supply your name, address, date of birth, Social Security number and other personal information. Fees vary based on where you live, but commonly range from $5 to $10.
- cmdrfred 10y agoIf anyone from Experian is reading this, for a low low free of $500/year I will refrain from making libelous comments[0]/defaming Experian and it's partners. Just remember to re-up after the offer expires! [0]Libelous comments will come from my "partners", so I can't be held responsible for the accuracy of those claims. Until then... Fun Fact: According to a anonymous source, the board of Experian eat children on Friday.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI see we're both on the same page regarding credit reporting agencies ;) I hold out hope the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts the screws to them after they're done with payday lenders.
- bogomipz 10y agoIs that who is behind that? Why does this agency not have a higher profile?
- softawre 10y agoIt must vary by state. Here in Indiana, it is free.
- bogomipz 10y agoBy locking your credit however you are denying them the future business of selling your credit profile. Think if everyone did it. But yes it's completely outrageous - you have to pay someone you didn't approve of having you data in the first place from giving it to another party likely did't approve of also having it.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI agree with you and your implications! Only through our efforts can we push back though.
- CrazyMusicians 10y ago
- droopyEyelids 10y agoYou're getting angry at the second level cascade of absurdity. The first level is realizing that "Identity theft" is a bullshit cover-your-ass scheme invented by banks and card networks to absolve themselves of responsibility for improperly securing their own systems. Consumer identities are never "stolen". Maybe a criminal gets to know some numbers associated with you. Then, the fraud protections of a bank are breached by a fraudster. Thats a crime between the fraudster and the bank, and it's really a crazy innovation to say the consumer is responsible for the loss in that situation.
- dnm 10y agoThis. I can't believe how the media/government has completely bought into the fact that the creditor (bank) failed to do proper due diligence in order to verify who they are extending credit to. And to make it seem like it's the fault of the person being impersonated is absurd. SSN as a password was the single biggest banking failure ever committed, aside from what happened in the 2000's mortgage debacle.
- mindslight 10y agoThe system runs on abstractions, which it inherently takes for granted as air-tight. Looking from inside the system, the abstraction of "identity" can never appear imperfect. So the observed behavior is described in terms of its internally-seen effects - an identity has been coopted by a bad actor, ergo it must have been stolen. I'm not endorsing the mislabeling, just explaining how it came about. Obviously sanity, sustainability, and individual freedom depend on pushing back against that system's prescriptions and "keeping it real".
- CocaKoala 10y agoThere's a comedy sketch from some group that talks about exactly this phenomenon. "Your identity has been stolen, sir" "Uh, I don't believe it has. I'm me, and I always have been." "Well, no, somebody came in and said they were you, and then they took all your money." "And you believed them? That was foolish. It sounds like this is a bank robbery to me." "No, no, no. We didn't get robbed. You got robbed. They took your money." "But you gave it to them, right? Even though they weren't me. This still sounds like your screw up here." edit: Ah ha, I found it! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- recursive 10y agoI was one of the people affected by this. I spent at least an hour trying to figure out if the paper letter I got was even legitimate, as it directed me to go to a domain I'd never heard of to enter personal details. Eventually, I figured out it was nominally legit, but then I figured out the same organization that leaked my info was asking for more personal info so they could protect me. I opted not to do anything, because I couldn't think of any course of action that would improve the situation, and I certainly wasn't going to voluntarily give Experian any more of my info.
- fapjacks 10y agoYes, I also spent time staring (fuming) at the paper letter I got.
- rogerbinns 10y ago> ... letter they sent to customers ... Experian's customers are not the people who received the letters. Their customers are those doing credit lookups for various reasons, and paying for it. Incentives matter, and Experian (et al) have an incentive to serve their customers, which is why they gather so much information and make it expensive, difficult, and inconvenient for their data subjects to withhold information. Unfortunately this state of affairs is going to be difficult to fix with regulation (you can bet they'll lobby hard against that).
- jsprogrammer 10y agoThey are actually prospective customers, as Experian is direct marketing a free trial of their product to the recipient.