5 ms·
My understanding of these flat metamaterial lenses is that they're fine-tuned for a single wavelength of light; you can't put one in a camera and expect it to w
by wlesieutre 10y ago
My understanding of these flat metamaterial lenses is that they're fine-tuned for a single wavelength of light; you can't put one in a camera and expect it to work like a glass lens did. I'm sure there are applications where control of monochromatic light is important, but I couldn't tell you what they are.
It's an awfully important detail to completely omit from an article.
- alcubierredrive 10y agoFor smartphones, where thinness is very important but area is less so, it would not be unprecedented to make an array of 4 monochromatic cameras and rectify and combine the images computationally. R G G B
- Strilanc 10y agoThat would treat monochromatic yellow light differently from yellow light made up of a combination of red and green, instead of treating them the same like the human eye does. The yellow of an actual banana would distort differently from the yellow coming from a picture of banana displayed on an LCD.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wlesieutre 10y agoEureka! We can make high precision, flat optics for Low Pressure Sodium lights! http://www.atmo.arizona.edu/students/courselinks/spring08/atmo336s1/courses/spring11/nats101s13/lecture_notes/em_radiation/Na_vapor_spectrum.png http://www.atmo.arizona.edu/students/courselinks/spring08/at...
- BurningFrog 10y agoUnfortunately, that is not how light and perception works. There are thousands/millions¹ of separate visible light frequencies. Our eyes and brains takes that all in and does an enormously lossy mapping of that to 3 perceived colors. If you only record 3 of those thousands/millions of frequencies, you will lose 99.9% of the light, and mostly make black photos. ¹ depending on how wide the frequency interval considered monochromatic is.
- Finnucane 10y agoIt _is_ possible to do trichromatic color photography with sets of single-color filters. In fact, the earliest color photography was done this way. Technicolor films were shot in a camera that recorded three monochromatic strips simultaneously. (it is true that the filters were generally not strictly a single color frequency, but a narrow band)
- alexbock 10y agoThe difference is that they were using film which was sensitive over the entire visible spectrum with color filters that allowed a broad range of wavelengths that are all perceived as the same color. If you had a smartphone camera filtered with a 1 nm bandpass filter for a particular wavelength, you're going to get so little light that it will be like taking pictures in the dark. The filter approach is still used in most cameras (Bayer filters) but a vary narrow wavelength bandpass would not be appropriate for a consumer camera.
- colanderman 10y agoAmount of light aside, the color rendition would be horrible too. Akin to the light from an RGB LED panel.
- dingo_bat 10y agoWhat's wrong with the color rendition of RGB panels? The newest ones are some of the most color accurate displays available.
- colanderman 10y agoI don't mean the images displayed on a panel; I mean the light from the panel if it were used to illuminate something else. Because you have only three narrow wavelengths of light, you lose 99% of the color information contained in the illuminated object's absorption spectrum. Actual LED lamps work around this issue by using phosphors to broaden the spectrum. This quality of light is measured by the Color Rendering Index; the phenomenon of color differences due to narrowband light sources is known as metamerism. The images displayed on a panel do not suffer this issue, because our eyes can detect only 3 "dimensions" of color; hence 3 narrowband illuminants suffice. (And in fact narrowband is necessary for a broad color gamut.) It is only when reflection/absorption comes into play that metamerism matters.
- wlesieutre 10y agoThe spectral transmission of a typical bayer filter is fairly wide, with the R G and B subpixels each capturing a large range of wave lengths. See http://blog.teledynedalsa.com/2012/11/ir-cut-filter-for-bayer-color-cameras/ http://blog.teledynedalsa.com/2012/11/ir-cut-filter-for-baye... for an example spectrum. You could get some image with single wavelength red, green, and blue sensors, and it might be pretty interesting looking, but it wouldn't see much like our eyes do.
- curiousgal 10y ago>thinness is very important For manufacturers but not for consumers, to an extent.
- stcredzero 10y agoI'm sure there are applications where control of monochromatic light is important, but I couldn't tell you what they are. What about VR headsets? Flat lenses are good in that case, and you'd just have to manipulate 3 wavelengths.
- wlesieutre 10y agoStill more than 3 wavelengths, even with OLED screens. Check out the gray line here: http://www.displaymate.com/Spectra_4.html http://www.displaymate.com/Spectra_4.html Maybe close enough that it would work, but I'm also not sure whether you can do these metamaterial lenses for three wavelengths at once. If it's even possible, AFAIK it's not a solved problem.
- anon1253 10y agoYep. Still useful for things like fluorescence microscopy or astrophotography though. There you're usually interested in just the specific wave length, like the (Green) Fluorescent Protein emissions for microscopes, or the Hydrogen Alpha emissions in astrophotography. Rather than working with filter sliders, you'd essentially need to use a different lens for each wave length though …
- outsidetheparty 10y agoAccording to the abstract (http://science.sciencemag.org/content/352/6290/1190 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/352/6290/1190), >Diffraction-limited focusing is demonstrated at wavelengths of 405, 532, and 660 nm with corresponding efficiencies of 86, 73, and 66%. ...but I'm not clear on whether that is from a single lens or if they constructed different lenses for each color. (Those wavelengths correspond to violet, green, and red light fwiw) EDIT: the full paper makes it clear this is three separate lenses, so yeah, you're right.
- ant6n 10y agoscreens separate out different colors into different areas at a small scale, wouldn't this work here as well?
- guelo 10y agoWhy couldn't multiple patterns sensitive to different frequencies be printed on the same surface?
- Natanael_L 10y agoUnless you can couple them with very tiny prisms, space + getting enough light is the problem.
- azernik 10y agoThe most obvious application of single-frequency lenses is in fiber optic communication transceivers (a single-frequency laser, or a series of such lasers in Wavelength Division Multiplexing). From my understanding these are a big source of component cost and failure rates. See e.g. http://www.panduit.com/heiler/InstallInstructions/PN541.pdf http://www.panduit.com/heiler/InstallInstructions/PN541.pdf
- JulianMorrison 10y agoHow about lasers? How about flat lasers, on chips, using laser diodes and flat lenses? Or camera pixels on the nano scale?
- BurningFrog 10y agoI can imagine a monochromatic microscope, where you can see the shape of tiny things, and you do not care about colors.
- ambicapter 10y agoChromatic aberration is already a thing. Are you saying that these lenses only work for a certain wavelength and their performance drop offs significantly when you go even slightly off-wavelength?