4 ms·
EFF Joins Coalition Opposing Dangerous CFAA Bill
- awinter-py 10y agoholy crud! CFAA already allows TOS writers to define any behavior as unauthorized & therefore a felony. Congressmen need a way to look strong on security without completely breaking rule of law. We should issue them nerf guns or something.
- tptacek 10y agoNo, it does not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Nosal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Nosal (Further: even without that case, CFAA never allowed TOS writers to invent their own felonies).
- sathackr 10y agoWasn't that the very basis of the Aaron Schwartz case? That, by violating the terms of use of the MIT site, he was violating the CFAA thus charged with multiple felonies? The linked case dealt with employees but I don't see why there should be a distinction. I would consider the general public to have even greater protections.
- tptacek 10y agoYou've worded this vaguely, but I think the answer to your question is "no, that is not a good description of the Swartz case".
- two2two 10y agoThis is a little different as it has to do with exceeding authorized access as an employee. The CFAA doesn't allow TOS writers to "invent" felonies, but it does allow for a basis of prosecution against someone who breaks it. Someone who siphons off data, breaking a TOS, will get treated the same as someone who lies on their dating profile. This is why the CFAA is too vague in its current form. We're expected to trust that only the "big guys" will be prosecuted under the CFAA, skirting the point of having the rule of law in the first place as no interpretation of a law should be left up to the discretion of a few men. As well, most people break at least 3 laws a day without knowing it, and they're likely breaking many more throughout the day online, just not getting prosecuted for it, but they could.
- tptacek 10y agoNope. Nosal has been used as a foundation to shoot down other cases for third-party TOS violations; see for instance Matot.
- pc86 10y agoSource?
- callcallcall 10y agoSome ways we can help fight the CFAA bill and support the EFF beyond complaining in HN comments: Learn: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act Call your representatives: TryVoices.com Donate to the EFF: https://supporters.eff.org/donate/ https://supporters.eff.org/donate/
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoI just emailed my Senators. People routinely underestimate the value of calmly and briefly explaining to elected leaders why they should vote one way or another.
- callcallcall 10y agoYes! People seem to forget how we defeated SOPA in 2012.
- Natsu 10y agoI think we'd be better off if we were the ones suggesting ways to define unauthorized access. I've thought about this quite a bit and I posted something on that subject about a week ago with my own suggested definition thereof. Quoting from that earlier comment: ===== For 'unauthorized access' to a computer system you (should) need to knowingly access a protected system in a way not permitted by the rights granted to you by the computer system, or by deliberate deception of either the computer systems or people. So for 'knowing' we have to actually know (via banners, etc.) that we're somewhere we shouldn't be. For 'protected' it has to be actually protected (none of this "I found unprotected files lying around with no password" nonsense). The last two clauses cover privilege escalation attacks and social engineering. So it should matter if you're operating the system normally or if you accidentally just click/type something wrong and found your way in vs. you were deliberately hacking / social engineering your way in. I'd also add a safe harbor for anyone who in good faith reported the issue to the site operators, police, or government regulatory bodies to prevent reprisal like this ugly case. Sadly, I don't get to write these laws.
- nxzero 10y agoDirect link to bill referenced in title: https://www.eff.org/files/2016/05/25/114th_may_2016_whitehouse_graham_blumenthal_botnet_bill.pdf https://www.eff.org/files/2016/05/25/114th_may_2016_whitehou...
- homero 10y agoVisitors are unauthorized to access this site. Your visit will be prosecuted.
- xufi 10y agoAlso in some cases. Smart psychologically Every click will help our site up to keep telling others that you're still unauthorized to view this site.
- beardog 10y agoGood news everyone, i hid a <img> to my server in this page, now you visited part of my site you were not authorized to! You are now all felons, see you in court.