5 ms·
What's the OLC's authority? Is their opinion binding?
by leereeves 10y ago
What's the OLC's authority? Is their opinion binding?
- scintill76 10y agoFrom above, "Opinions issued by the OLC are generally treated as binding and final within the executive branch." So they don't have any legal authority or hierarchy per se since they're two parts of one legally defined branch of the government, but apparently the OLC is supposed to be the authority.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not formally binding. But the executive is a single entity under the President. Constitutionally, the FBI doesn't have any independence. The OLC is like the executive's in-house legal counsel. One part of the executive ignoring its opinions is like having a division in your company ignoring your legal department's opinions and coming to its own conclusions. It represents a failure of leadership at the top.
- krashnburn200 10y agoIf by leadership you mean fire the instigator of the asshattery then I agree with you.
- rayiner 10y agoSure. But failure to fire the people being insubordinate is also a failure of the President's leadership.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThe people being insubordinate may well not be political appointees that serve at the pleasure of the President and who therefore could be fired by the President (and, procedurally, the President can't directly institute the processes which would lead to firing them, either), and while the President can fire the political appointees above them, the President can't replace those political appointees without the cooperation of the Senate (unless the opportunity for a recess appointment pops up.)
- ryanlol 10y agoFailure to fire those political appointees for not firing insubordinates is hardly defensible.
- Pica_soO 10y agoWenn das der Führer wüsste..
- dragonwriter 10y ago> But the executive is a single entity under the President. Given that Congress constitutionally can, and does, assign functions directly to specific entities within the executive branch, the concept of the unitary executive, while not entirely lacking in validity, is limited even as a description of the Constitutional structure, much less practical and political reality. > The OLC is like the executive's in-house legal counsel. No, its not. Its like outside (advisory but not trial, as the latter function is handled by, well, much of the rest of DoJ) counsel to executive branch entities other than DoJ, which all, in fact, also have their own in-house counsel.