3 ms·
Does that meet your definition of "supervised training"? I think as a second layer, yes. To your original statement though, being alone is the same as no-one
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
Does that meet your definition of "supervised training"?
I think as a second layer, yes.
To your original statement though, being alone is the same as no-one teaching them to talk.
Adults, and other children, in fact teach infants to talk. It might not seem explicit (though there are very explicit programs for infant language development) but in fact it works the same way. See my other comment about object segmentation and classification.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> To your original statement though, being alone is the same as no-one teaching them to talk. No it's not. You can have one without the other. Being alone implies no one teaching them to talk. However, children who are not alone still learn to talk despite no one teaching them.
- AndrewKemendo 10y ago>However, children who are not alone still learn to talk despite no one teaching them. This is where we disagree. The distinction is that you probably see training/teaching as intentional - but it's not always. You can (and do) learn just by watching and listening without it being an explicit procedural training. Simply being around others = being taught.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoAgain, congenitally deaf children who cannot learn any language spoken by the adults around them (since they can't perceive the speech) nevertheless create sign languages among themselves when they are part of a community of deaf children, and those sign languages display the full complexity and expressivity of any natural language. These de novo languages cannot have been taught to the children because they didn't exist to be taught. They are a product of the interaction between children, a side effect. The same thing happens among the children of pidgin-speaking communities -- they receive input that does not belong to any language and, acting as a group, construct a full language from that. (This process is called creolization.) But the case of deaf children is especially clear because they don't even receive the malformed linguistic input that creolizing children do.