4 ms·
You may think nothing is noble about war, but by and large, you're probably in disagreement with the majority of the ~120 billion humans who have ever lived. Pa
by jcranmer 10y ago
You may think nothing is noble about war, but by and large, you're probably in disagreement with the majority of the ~120 billion humans who have ever lived. Particularly in the 18th and 19th centuries, war was generally seen as a noble thing and generally a focal part of high culture. Think of the glorious portrayal of "doomed last stands"--the Alamo, Pickett's Charge, the Charge of the Light Brigade. It's largely only WWI (it should be noted that the German High Command fairly indisputably saw a coming Great War as an ultimately good thing--the dispute is mostly in how much this influenced their actions immediately prior to the war) that created a massive cultural cynicism in the portrayal of war. And even after WWI and the Vietnam War, we've again returned to a condition where glorifying war is a sure moneyspinner (even if critics tend to be less thrilled about it).
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoYes, you've sorta made out point-we don't live in the pre-20th century world, the world of those battles are long gone. And the American Civil War was (since you mentioned Pickett's Charge) more of a porto-WW1 in many respects rather than some sort of bizarre image of a masculine gentleman's war that you seem to have.
- vacri 10y agoNapoleon himself stated that you had to trick the common man into going to war. Hitler said similar as well. War is glorified so people continue to be soldiers and kings get their muscle, but it's just not true that the majority of people who have ever lived think that war is noble - particularly those who have seen war. History also doesn't talk about most of the endless numbers of doomed last stands, only the occasional one gets special mention. > we've again returned to a condition where glorifying war is a sure moneyspinner Not so in continental Europe. The US has barely had it's homelands touched in half a dozen generations - the US people are very removed from the reality of war, so revelling in the glory has little tangible cost these days. One example is that the entire decade-plus of US involvement in Iraq has seen fewer US deaths than the bloodiest single day in WWI saw (counting all sides), yet American talking heads keep on crapping on about the 'high' level of US casualties in Iraq. > the Charge of the Light Brigade Depends on your nationality. For Australians, our 'Charge of the Light Brigade' was a great success. :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Beersheba_%281917%29#Light_Horse_charge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Beersheba_%281917%29...
- dfc 10y agoI am probably in disagreement with ~100 billion humans when it comes to gender equality, slavery, appropriate treatment of venereal diseases, geocentrism, etc. What am I to conclude from this disagreement? For me the "doomed last stands" have more to do with courage, sacrifice and commitment to a greater principle than the state of persistent and coordinated violence between two parties. I am also disagreement when it comes to equating self serving policies for nation states or commercial enterprises with "nobleness."