7 ms·
A Car’s Computer Can ‘Fingerprint’ You in Minutes Based on How You Drive
- JimLaheyMD 10y ago"In a study they plan to present at the Privacy Enhancing Technology Symposium in Germany this July" How would this enhance privacy? It seems like it would do the opposite?
- bowmessage 10y agoOne needs to understand how to thwart privacy in order to gain their own.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Bromskloss 10y agoI guess it can make sense to give a lecture about war on a peace conference.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- recursive 10y agoThis is exactly the reason they would never consider lock-picking techniques at lock symposium.
- fryguy 10y agoAnd hacking techniques at a computer security conference.
- Sanddancer 10y agoAt the end of the article, they discuss how the report stresses a need for more secure transmission systems on the CAN bus, as well as potentially including things like permissions-based security
- evanwolf 10y agoIt's just another biometric matching system. So it might be used as a form of sign-in to your car's network or data, better than taking your hands off the wheel to key a password. Or a LoJack complement that identifies your car's thief.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DrScump 10y ago<With 90 minutes driving data or monitoring more car components, they could pick out the correct driver fully 100 percent of the time.> With 90 minutes of data, they could pick out one driver out of a sample size of 15. How meaningful is that, really?
- Terribledactyl 10y agoI think they meant 15/15 drivers which is a little better, but yeah.
- DrScump 10y ago"...could let them correctly distinguish the correct driver out of 15 individuals about nine times out of ten, after just 15 minutes of driving." So, the claim is 90% accuracy in determining which one of the fifteen drivers they are looking at. So, they were correct on 13.5 drivers. Um, what?
- rosser 10y agoTry parsing it as "90% of drives", not of drivers.
- DrScump 10y agoThat doesn't make sense to me. The constraint is 15 minutes total. If drives vs drivers give different data, that could only imply that (a) each driver's 15 minutes spans multiple vehicles, or (b) they make conflicting conclusions for the same driver across multiple trips.
- rosser 10y agoYou're reading constraints into the experiment that don't appear to exist. My take is that after 15 minutes of driving the algorithm could correctly identify which driver was behind the wheel. That means: I get in, start driving, and within 15 minutes or so, the system analyzing the car's internal network will, with 90% specificity, say, "The driver was 'rosser." I don't see where you're coming up with only 15 minutes total driving. That isn't implied anywhere in The Fine Article. But even leaving that detail aside, it would actually be more impressive than the reported finding if they were correctly identifying people that well after only 15 minutes total!
- pessimizer 10y agoI'm surprised it took 90 minutes; I'd imagine that it'd only take two or three. The data is very rich and continuous, and the knowledge is almost entirely reflexive. I would also think that identifying typists wouldn't take much longer. Does anybody know of any papers on that? You could pull that off with javascript.
- tacon 10y agoI don't know of any papers, but for verified certificates from Coursera, you validate your identity via a webcam selfie and typing their one sentence honor code into an input field.
- AdamTReineke 10y agoDirect link to the publication: http://www.autosec.org/pubs/fingerprint.pdf http://www.autosec.org/pubs/fingerprint.pdf
- sandworm101 10y agoTalk about doing things the hard way. With 15 people, I'd bet you could determine the driver simply by the weight sensor in the driver's seat. No need to do any actual driving. You could probably make some progress with radio station settings (volume/channel etc) or even how they adjust the seats/mirrors.
- ganeshkrishnan 10y agoNot all sensors are available all the time. I was creating a prototype dash cam that recorded drivers driving habits and AR of obstacles on the path in addition to GPS routing. The best way to "log on" a driver was analyze driving pattern and assign records to that person
- Retra 10y agoWeight is only one dimensional though, so you'll have more collisions. If two people happen to weigh about the same, then your weight sensor is useless and your driving analysis is not.
- lorenzhs 10y agoIt's far from useless, it limits the pool of candidates to two. Far easier to distinguish two drivers from each other than fifteen.
- manicdee 10y agoAnd the article points out that they can already distinguish drivers with 90% accuracy based on the throttle sensor alone after 15 minutes of sampling. With extra sensors or more time, they get much closer to 100%. So yes, you(s) are all correct. With one sensor you get decent accuracy, with more you get improved accuracy. Noting that these are forensic assessments, and thus useless for personalising car settings when a new driver gets into the vehicle.
- ThomPete 10y agoWouldn't this mean that you could do that too based on mouse movement? I.e. couldn't you create a security system based on how you use your mouse?
- zerooneinfinity 10y agoI think you are on to something.
- pmiller2 10y agoBeen done: http://www.cs.wm.edu/~hnw/paper/ccs11.pdf http://www.cs.wm.edu/~hnw/paper/ccs11.pdf
- geggam 10y agoWas an Ex Ebay'r founded startup tried to recruit me. The mouse movement was part of their security product. Not sure what else they were doing or what happened to them.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoI suppose it would depend on the driver. I know a few people I could fingerprint with the lousy IMU built into my ears with no computer analysis - some go constantly from the white line to the yellow line and back, some don't realize that the accelerator works at input levels below 10%, some second-guess the automatic transmission at every shift...but many drive, well, normally. Regarding the mouse or keyboard inputs discussed in this thread, there are a few hunt-and-peckers or over-correctors who would similarly be found. I don't think it's that impressive to get a few drivers out of a sample, they likely have detectable quirks.
- sverige 10y agoThe privacy concern is valid. It won't be long before all new cars are sending data from the sensors to third parties, and it would be unthinkable for the manufacturers to ask for your consent before collecting that data since they'll make money off of it. The article mentions concerns with insurance companies. One I worked for tried to get customers to agree to having their rates adjusted based on data from their cars. It was mostly to do with how many miles the customer drove, but I think there was also an element that looked at speed coupled with GPS data to determine if they habitually exceeded the speed limit. There was a lot of pushback from customers and privacy advocates at the time and it didn't really go anywhere at the time (2007-08 iirc) but since that time I recall hearing of another company doing just that with some volunteers. Now imagine the insurer has access to everything on the CAN bus. Your rates could go up based on taking curves too fast, braking too hard too often, or following too close. The law enforcement angle is disturbing too. Then there's the nightmare of the advertising people getting hold of it, complete with GPS data. God knows what they'd do with it exactly, but whatever it is, it will be sleazy and annoying by definition. Time to include this on the list of things to oppose for privacy's sake.
- vmarsy 10y ago>taking curves too fast, braking too hard too often I was thinking about this the other day, people driving in San Francisco or Seattle hills would then have higher rates than people driving on flat Texas roads? People stuck in rush hours (where no matter how smoothly you try to drive, there will be more hard brakes) would have higher rates than people who can avoid it? regardless of the number of car accidents in the area?
- eru 10y agoObviously, you'd want to use some more (and more useful) features to calculate your price. (Otherwise, your insurance company will lose out to the competition that prices better. You overcharge low-risk drivers who will leave to a cheaper alternative for them, and are left with the high-risk drivers who cost you a lot.) The area you are driving in is an obvious candidate. Or even the particular roads you are driving on at particular hours.
- King-Aaron 10y agoI bet my 40mm Webber can't.
- btbuildem 10y agoGood thing self-driving cars are coming, then.
- 88e282102ae2e5b 10y agoI wonder if you could defeat this by using your left foot (assuming the fingerprinting was done when you used your right foot).
- AuzzieStig 10y agoI scratched my head reading this thinking "Why would using the clutch change things" also made me think of two things, one being that yes i believe that swapping your primary foot your using would most likely cause different driving patters much like swapping where your hands are sitting on the steering wheel would have a similar effect. And two is i wonder if there would be an improvement in recognition time if the car being tested had a manual transmission adding common shift patterns to the equation.
- coroutines 10y agoSo... I'm expecting surveillance like driver fingerprinting + that shit Progressive is doing with "Snapshot" to be used to really penalize drivers in the future for the slightest mishap. I hate driving - especially in California. Automate all the things.