3 ms·
I don't suggest that the thrown starfish are returning, but perhaps that others nearby might be moving into the test area. But it would have been interesting t
by sandworm101 10y ago
I don't suggest that the thrown starfish are returning, but perhaps that others nearby might be moving into the test area. But it would have been interesting to tag them and see if they were in fact coming home
The use of a nearby control, or for that matter any control, is based on the assumption that absent the differential treatment there should be no observed change. I'd say that in selecting a pair of control and experimental areas one should first monitor them over a significant period of time to establish that they are stable or at least similar enough. Otherwise a change that was inevitable in one but not the other will appear to have been the result of the experiment.
I'd want to see more samples and some sort of region-wide survey to establish whether the baseline populations are in flux region-wide.