5 ms·
The most interesting definition I have seen of consciousness is [1] "the mind thinking about the mind thinking", i.e. some sort of meta-level "diagnostic proces
by gpderetta 10y ago
The most interesting definition I have seen of consciousness is [1] "the mind thinking about the mind thinking", i.e. some sort of meta-level "diagnostic process".
What I find interesting is that this definition supports awareness and an the existence of an 'I', but doesn't imply any sort of control or direct influence on the unconscious mind for which there seem to be experimental evidence against. Instead the result of this (literal) 'reflection' would be fed back to the unconscious mind as a sensorial input as any other.
Such a reflective process could possibly arise evolutionarily as it is a way to improve the efficiency of the thought processes.
I know absolutely nothing about neural network, but I wonder what would happen if the time series of the internal signals of a NN was fed to another NN and its output back into the first NN. Probably nothing stable at all and training would be 'interesting'.
Another interesting thing is that consciousness would be 'just' a process and not necessary for intelligence to arise. Peter Watts in 'Blindsight' [2] explores this last point in depth.
[1] Unfortunately I can't remember were I read this reference nor I have been able to track it.
[2] An extremely good first contact hard scifi novel, can be read for free from the author website.
- c54 10y agoSo do we not mean "conscious" as the opposite of "unconscious"? As in it's possible to knock out a dog - rendering it unconscious. But when it wakes back up it's not going to think about the fact that it's a dog (as far as we know). So what's the name for a dog's normal not-unconscious waking state?
- gpderetta 10y agoyou are confusing begin unconscious, i.e. in a comatose state, with consciousness. Other than the similarity of the words, they have little in common. Being unconscious might imply that the mind is running in a state of little or no consciousness, but it is not defined by that. Assuming a cat or dog has no consciousness, it would still be called 'conscious' in his waking state.
- brownbat 10y agoThat's a reasonable question, these terms aren't very clear. Philosophers who work on these issues tend to separate out individual aspects of conscious experience and discuss them under distinct terms, for clarity and precision. The main article isn't really following these conventions (most people don't even know about them), but for philosophy: Consciousness is generally the state of having subjective experiences. Like, you're conscious when you have some personal experience of things. Sapience is the capacity to act with reflective judgment. This definition is a mess, just bear with me for now. Self-awareness is, well, awareness of one's self. Introspection. There are probably others I can't recall right now. All of these are slightly different aspects of a phenomena we experience as humans, and we tend to lump them all together when talking about it, especially when asking if nonhumans can exhibit any of these properties. I think what we mean when talking about "conscious AI" is probably something more like "sapient AI" (possibly just "self-aware AI?"). A few millenia of discussion about the meaning of sapience summarized here: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wisdom/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wisdom/
- tim333 10y agoThinking about thinking might be a bit over demanding - we still tend to consider people conscious when they are reading HN for example. People definitely can think about thinking though so a system wouldn't be human level if it couldn't so that.
- gpderetta 10y agoyou are taking the 'thinking about thinking' too litteraly (that would be 'thinking about thinking about thinking'). For your HN example, reading itself would be an unconscious process, you becoming aware of the words as they get processed on your mind and acquiring meaning and triggering recollections and additional side thoughts is the conscious meta process.
- dwaltrip 10y agoThe definition I use is very similar. I like to think of consciousness or sentience as the ability to model (or predict) one's self. A pattern-matching entity that can match its own patterns. I might disagree about the intelligence aspect. It seems to me any entity that is at least moderately interesting (has any kind of behavioral complexity) would need some level of intelligence in order to model itself to a respectable degree.
- mh-cx 10y agoNot really a definition, but my very personal take on what conciousness is: Evolution has brought about creatures that are more successful (in regard to survival and reproduction), the more predictive power they have about their environment[1]. One could say, the better a species can simulate it's environment, the more likely it will continue to exist and be part of the ongoing evolution. Our brains are of course also just products of this evolutionary process and meanwhile very good at simulating their environment. Now if we think about Plato's cave we could say, that all our experience is just an illusion. It's all just a projection of reality, that our brain creates. I'd go a step further and say: Experience or qualia is what the process of simulation of reality feels like. Or to put it in another way: Conciousness is the process of simulation of reality. The "better" the simulation or the more complete and closer to "reality" it is (whatever that means) - the higher the form of conciousness. Taking this definition one must also concede that even animals and "lower" life forms have some degree of conciousness. It probably feels like something to be a streptococcus. Of course all this is just blind speculation - but it somehow feels right to me. [1] https://www.quantamagazine.org/20151119-life-is-information-adami/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/20151119-life-is-information-...
- Xcelerate 10y ago> Conciousness is the process of simulation of reality. The "better" the simulation or the more complete and closer to "reality" it is (whatever that means) - the higher the form of conciousness. So would you say that a supercomputer in the process of calculating the gyromagnetic ratio of an isolated electron to 12 digits of accuracy is a higher form of consciousness than we are? After all, it is performing a much better simulation of reality than our brains in that case.
- mh-cx 10y agoNo, because it only simulates a very small part of reality. For example it could never estimate the weather for the next 2 hours by looking at a formation of heavy clouds.
- deleted 10y ago
- kirrent 10y agoDouglass Hoffstadter wrote about consciousness like this in many of his metamagical themas columns. By analogy he mused that consciousness might arise as a higher level construct which would watch and supervise lower level functions. While he didn't really bother to develop his arguments too far the articles all had a very enjoyable Hosffstadterian writing style that made them a real pleasure to read.
- CardenB 10y agoWhat you're referring to about NNs fed into one another sounds similar to generative adversarial nets. They are indeed able to optimise but they're very effective. Though far from consciousness.
- gpderetta 10y agoFrom some quick googling, they don't seem what I have in mind. The nets are still trained one from the output of the other or from external data. I want a net to be fed with the internal state of another net. But maybe it doesn't make sense.
- SubiculumCode 10y agoThis is the field of meta-cognition in cognitive psychology
- Strilanc 10y agoThat's introspection. It's distinct from the hard problem of consciousness. Consider that it's not difficult to make computer programs that introspect. A quine is a trivial example. But since people argue over whether computer programs can be conscious, and it's dead obvious that some computer programs introspect (i.e. operate on their own source code or perform diagnostics on their own state), I think it's clear that people have more than just introspection in mind when they say "consciousness".