5 ms·
I find it quite interesting that a similar number of 50% of men who enter the teacher profession also leaves while the number for women is about half. In stark
by belorn 10y ago
I find it quite interesting that a similar number of 50% of men who enter the teacher profession also leaves while the number for women is about half. In stark contrast however, the quote text, the theory on why men drops out of female dominated professions share nothing in common with the theories on why women leave male dominated.
In a 2009 report by the Swedish national agency, they argue that the reason why people drop out at a higher rate compared to the dominating gender is that the work culture integrate gender identity when there is unequal gender ratios, and the more a individual work and study, the more are they forced to either assimilate into that culture or quit. Compared to the argument about "lower chance of being promoted", a hostile culture seems much more likely as a root cause to high drop rate, and I would be surprised if culture crashes had no correlation with promotion rates.
- busterarm 10y agoAnecdotal, but my cousin was a primary school teacher and faced an incredible amount of hostility because of his gender from parents and colleagues and left for construction after 2 years.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWesterners seem to have a serious distrust in men when it comes to young children. A woman talking to kids in a park is most obviously a mom. A man talking to kids in a park is most obviously a paedophile.
- andrepd 10y agoAt least where I come from I do not feel that in the slightest.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI envy you. I feel weird when dealing with children for exactly that reason.
- andrepd 10y agoThat's very odd. I can see why parents want to be protective, but immediately shielding a kid if a male interacts playfully with them seems an overreaction.
- enraged_camel 10y agoIt's very common. I have a friend who got the cops called on him when he took his 3-year old daughter to the park one day. He said it took a while to prove that he was a) the father and b) he hadn't abducted the daughter.
- throwaway293810 10y agoWhere did that happen? I'm not doubting you in the slightest -- just interested in data points (my gut says maybe somewhere in the South, if this is the US, or somewhere rural?) Also, any factors he thinks might have contributed -- e.g., daughter crying, or does he have a big bushy beard, or was there a crazy parent who had a bad interaction with him, or...? That sort of reaction from authorities is just absolutely chilling, no matter the case.
- Natsu 10y agoIt is an overreaction, but it's a common one. I'd like to believe it's all horror stories, but it's more than enough to create a chilling effect.
- bravura 10y agoTrans-men report the opposite: http://time.com/transgender-men-sexism/ http://time.com/transgender-men-sexism/ 'Most trans men I spoke to also identified another commonality: Once they transitioned [from female to male], walking became easier, but talking became harder. To be more specific: walking home after dark felt easier, casually talking to babies, strangers and friends felt harder. “I have to be very careful to not be staring at kids,” says Gardner. “I can look at a mom and her baby, but I can’t look for too long. I miss being seen as not a threat.” Ditto for kids on the playground and puppies, multiple guys said.'
- hkmurakami 10y agoSeems to be the case in the East as well, judging from what I've read.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Ntrails 10y agoIf I see a random child and they look at me, I used to ignore them. Not because I don't think it's hilarious to stick my tongue out or make a face - but because I was worried what someone might think. And, hell, I'm only 30 - it will only get worse as I get older. I decided that I would not bow to that absurdity, and now I choose to say hello, or run away, or say "boo" or whatever takes my fancy in interacting with said child. Because it's amusing getting a response, watching them process the event and make a decision on how to react. I'd still be nervous if I saw a child without obvious supervision though. To try and help, or not to try and help...
- jbob2000 10y agoIn Ontario, male teachers are not allowed to take children to the washroom, even if the child is a boy. This is a problem because if a child with a disability needs to use the washroom, he needs to wait until a female staff member is available. I understand why men would drop out of the school system. Before you even start, you're already considered a predator.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andrepd 10y agoI hardly think that particular case (abhorrent and indefensible though it is) is indicative of the statu quo.
- deciplex 10y agoAny reason for that? I mean, it's anecdotal evidence, sure, but it's not the first time I've heard such a story about how men are treated in the teaching profession. It's only one data point, but even a single data point is superior to the no data points you've countered with.
- andrepd 10y agoWell, all of the schools that do not enforce such a ridiculous rule are my data points. So unless you suggest there are more schools enforcing that rule than not, then I have more data points, so I win. Right? The truth is that that anecdote brings no value whatsoever to the discussion.
- deciplex 10y agoIt brings a little value, in the form of a single data point. Not "none" otherwise no one could talk about their experiences ever, without being accused of wasting everyone's time. Also, there need not be more than 50% of schools enforcing this policy, for it to discourage men from entering the profession. Even 10% would be a lot.
- vlehto 10y agoThis is completely anecdotal, but I've noticed that gender ratios in groups in general create pretty harmonouus groups if they fall in ranges of 40% - 60% or <10%. Like put 4 women and 6 men in a group, they come along. Or put one man and 9 women in a group, they come along. Put 3 guys and 7 women into a group and there is constant power struggle. This seems to be more true for kids. Small minority is likely to adapt or leave. Close to 50/50 ratio genders balance each other out. With strong minority the minority tries to have balanced group, but the majority wants to engage in "guy talk" or girl talk". The way men interact with other men and how women interact with other women seem to be one of the most distinct differences between genders.
- facepalm 10y ago"they argue" They speculate, you mean? Those are all "just so" stories...
- facepalm 10y agoDo you have a citation for the "50% of male teachers leave"? I'd be interested in the details. Thanks!
- belorn 10y agoRapport 2009:7 R, Swedish national agency of higher education. A start would be to read page 18 and down, but the conclusions on page 31 and 56 is what most of my comment is based on. To translate a section with title "why do men drop out": "Our conclusion, somewhat simplified, are three main root causes. First, men who start studying to become a teacher can be less convinced in their decision, because they are walking outside societies norms and are not doing a typical male job, and thus the decision to become a teacher is questioned from the beginning. The second reason is that men are faced with a traditional feminine culture which they either have to assimilate or rebel to, both which makes life more difficult. Thirdly, there are few male role models compare to female role models."
- facepalm 10y agoBut do give any indications that these are the real causes, or are they also just speculating as so many others do when it comes to explaining those phenomena? Did they study the causes at all? Or did they just note "50% drop out" and then jump to the conclusion that it must be because x? Thanks for translating.