2 ms·
Just because something is in 3D doesn't make it automatically better -- often times it's worse as you now have artificial constraints that you didn't have befor
by azinman2 10y ago
Just because something is in 3D doesn't make it automatically better -- often times it's worse as you now have artificial constraints that you didn't have before. For example, it's far easier to scroll through Instagram with your fingers (a UI win) and have every photo at 100% scale than to glide through a 3d representation where much more work has to be done. Certainly you wouldn't want the world to scroll you in VR -- you'd throw up.
This was true before with SL, and it'll be true with VR in the future. It'll be great for certain kinds of games, therapy, housing walk throughs, and other contexts for which a synthetic 3D world is useful, but it won't be the panacea that replaces all other forms of UI. Immersion also has a cost -- it's very intense and you don't want it for hours and hours and hours. Just like you'd never want to be on a rollercoaster for 8h, VR for 8h will also be too much (unless the world itself is not an intense game, you don't have a screen 2" from your eyeballs, etc).
- napworth 10y agoCorrect. However on the otherhand, walking around a 3D art gallery where each wall is dedicated to one of the accounts you are following would be a benecicial use of the technology. You could easily scan the small framed images for those you like, and click on them to visualise them at full size in front of you.
- azinman2 10y agoHave you tried this? I've done a couple of 3d museums in the oculus & cardboard and it's a terrible experience. Scanning small images is not an improved experience over existing feeds on mobile phones, especially for something where you end up only looking at a photo you like for 0.4-2 seconds anyway.
- GauntletWizard 10y agoIf the content is 2d, I imagine a 2d interface is the right way to view it. Real paintings aren't 2d, though - Even modern fully-computerized paintings are actually 3d planar constructs, because artists use many layers in their construction, though that's often not exposed. Real paintings have brushstrokes, bumps, texture and depth. Even the most high-res scans of paintings utterly fail to capture that. The Met has a fantastic collection of art scans that you can browse online[1]. Some of those works are stunning, even in thumbnails. But they still pale in comparison to how they are when you're up close, when you can see the grain of the canvas, the brushstrokes and dabs of paint, the way that it all pieces together. I always view a painting from multiple angles, looking from the left and right, tilting my head. Texture matters, a lot. VR can provide that in a way a 2d (or even flat 3d) monitor never could. The real promise is an endless, densely packed 3d museum, where you can single out an exhibit, open it in it's own room, and enlarge/move it as you see fit. You walk down the aisle, viewing many pieces in an infinite array, and zoom in when you like one. You get many constantly changing angles, which is what our brains were built to deal with. It's not there yet. Tilt Brush gives us a taste. More will come. [1] http://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection http://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection
- azinman2 10y agoI feel like it's missing a lot of the point of museums. It's like asking why go to Japan when you can just virtual walk around Tokyo? Experience is far more than just tricking yourself visually, and it's more than just being able to look at brush strokes up close in 3D. Instead of reproducing existing things poorly that you seldom want to do anyway, VR should be about doing things that are either impossible in real life or are compelling enough even if done in a non-realistic form.
- BOBOTWINSTON 10y agoI agree with the key point here: VR will not replace all other forms of UI. It is a mistake to look at VR UIs as strictly 3D. There is no reason you could not scroll through your photos on a 2D screen with your fingers in VR. You can even have the added benefit of spawning multiple giant 2D screens, then grabbing photos off them for a scrap book or a virtual art gallery. I've shared a great deal of locomotion experiences with other Vive owners. VR sickness seems a lot rarer than it was hyped up to be, and definitely a lot easier to acclimate to. I wonder how many vomiting journalists would be fine if they eased into it over a day or two. I can fly around in Windlands without flinching these days. Don't get me wrong, nausea is still a real design constraint, but we might be a lot more adaptive to VR and weird locomotion. On the topic of session lengths, I firmly believe this is just an issue with content and ergonomics. I've done a few 6 hours sessions in multiplayer games, the problem is barely any exist. I haven't heard anyone experience "immersion fatigue", but some games will cause actual physical fatigue. Thankfully I already stand all day and it isn't an issue. I think if you already can play a game for 8 hours, VR will be there to provide the same in the future.
- BatFastard 10y agoOne BIG problem with SL is a horrible, hard to use, unintuitive UI. -- It's easy to make things hard to use, it's hard to make them easy to use. --
- laksjd 10y agoI think this is the underlying cause for many of the failed projects from the 'Second Life bubble'. Many human activities, especially those related to information intake and processing have a long history of being 2D. From clay tablets to paper books, from the first photograph to 4K television, virtually all of the information designed for human consumption has been 2D. Only an incredibly small percentage is in 3D and even less is designed to be consumed in 3D (e.g. video games are often 3D internally but are designed for 2D consumption). This might or might not change in the future but if it does it will be changing neither soon nor rapidly. Yes, one can use 2D interfaces inside 3D worlds but any 3D system short of the matrix will have a noticeable quality degradation (e.g. visual fidelity, haptic feedback, fatigue, etc) compared to directly using a 2D interface in real life. A few edge cases might become feasible much sooner, e.g. using VR to emulate large screens but that's hardly 'Virtual Reality'. Until we come up with meaningful ways to represent more kinds of information in 3D and/or create a matrix-style experience, VR will most likely be limited to applications that are inherently 3D. This obviously includes entertainment (VR games, 'movies', 3D art) and CAD/CAM/3D modelling which are already very much 3D in nature and internal representation, even if they are currently usually projected onto 2D screens. Outside of that, the main 'educational' usage currently consists of building 3D environments (labs, buildings, factories, complex machinery) that emulate real-life environments in order to familiarize trainees with the workflows in those places. This can be surprisingly effective, especially considering how much cheaper VR mockups are compared to e.g. NASA's real-life 1:1 ISS training replica. These applications are worthwhile in their own right and they will probably be able to sustain a decent market for VR hardware and development. However, I'm personally much more interested in seeing what kind of concepts that aren't already inherently 3D can be enhanced or revolutionized by adding another dimension.