3 ms·
I don't believe in this (relatively recent) trend of associating AI with bodies. Why should AIs need bodies? Clearly AIs without bodies must be possible. Of co
by Tichy 17y ago
I don't believe in this (relatively recent) trend of associating AI with bodies. Why should AIs need bodies? Clearly AIs without bodies must be possible.
Of course if you want AI that resembles humans, bodies might help. But why specialize too soon (creating AI is easier than creating AI that is like humans).
- warfangle 17y agoI think it's in terms of sensory input and area of control that causes the brain/body size : smarts correlation. If the brain has to worry less about controlling massive amounts of tissue (and dealing with all of the sensory input that entails), it is "free" to become more advanced. One of the keys may be to be very selective about the kind and quantity of input and outputs the AI can have: the less it has to control itself, the more it can think. Purely speculative, of course.
- TeHCrAzY 17y agoI think you have the right idea. My idea was immediately along the lines of "if you have less to control, you can devote more hardware to control it", which would seemingly produce higher levels of perceived intelligence.
- gnosis 17y ago"I don't believe in this (relatively recent) trend of associating AI with bodies." The problem is that "strong AI" (ie. an AI considered intelligent in the deepest sense of the term, with intelligence equal to or greater than that of a human) has pretty much run in to a dead end. Lots of approaches have been tried over the decades, and all have failed. Strong AI research needs new ideas and new approaches. Making a close coupling between the "brain" (or "mind") and the body is one such relatively new approach. As such, I applaud it. Like the approaches that came before, it also might lead up a blind alley. But at least they're trying something new and different, instead of banging their head on the same wall. And, apart from the sheer novelty of the approach, there has been a lot of evidence that much of the "processing" that has been assumed to be done in the brain is actually done in the body. Some relatively recent robotics research has been focused on creating robots without any kind of a "brain", but just with a "nervous system". These robots are able to move around and achieve goals. Here's some information on a conference where these sorts of robots are demonstrated: http://ine-web.org/telluride-conference-2010/telluride-2010/index.html http://ine-web.org/telluride-conference-2010/telluride-2010/... These robots are a far cry from achieving the goal of strong AI, but they point to an alternative approach to AI that is not brain-centric, to coin a term.
- marshallp 17y ago"Lots of approaches have been tried over the decades, and all have failed." I beg to differ with that. Marvin Minsky's idea of having 5000 people creating a common sense database of sorts wasn't tried. (the closest is cyc, which only had 20 people most of the time). Genetic programming has not been tried at all really. Machine learning hasn't been seriously tried either (the closest efforts have been google goggles and google search maybe). AI is serious and complicated engineering project. Billions are spent on creating skyscapers, tunnels, and airplanes. Yet the money spent on AI is orders of magnitude less even though the payoff is orders of magnitude more. If I had to guess, I'd say AI would be easily achievable within a year using any of the above approaches if a trillion dollars were spent on it this year.
- eru 17y agoI beg to differ. All the approaches you mentioned are still under heady investigation. It's only the name of AI that has been tarnished. And the progress in the tools will eventually lead to more "intelligent" systems.
- marshallp 17y agoWhat do you mean by 'heavy investigation'. The latest skyscrapers in dubai cost billions of dollars each. How much is spent on AI per year worldwide. I'd bet it's less than 100 million. I wouldn't call that serious effort. How has the name of AI been tarnished. If people believe you can spend a fraction of the money spent on a building to create human level intelligence then it's their 'intelligence' that is tarnished. If your goal is create human level ai, than more 'intelligent' systems is not progress, we've had 'intelligent' tools since the first loom weaving machines were created hundreds of years ago.
- coffeeaddicted 17y agoThe game industry does spend some money on AI development. Not sure if it's 100 million, but it's a serious amount as most game development teams have at least one or two AI developers. Although most people probably don't realize how much game AI has advanced in the last decade as most of the advances had been to cope with increasingly complex game worlds.