5 ms·
Peter Thiel funding a lawsuit is far from the center of power and social control. In this, he's merely a petitioner, hoping the true center of power and social
by leereeves 10y ago
Peter Thiel funding a lawsuit is far from the center of power and social control.
In this, he's merely a petitioner, hoping the true center of power and social control (the courts and lawmakers) will act in his favor.
- zem 10y agoexcept that having effectively unlimited amounts of money to keep throwing at a lawsuit is a depressingly good predictor of success.
- leereeves 10y agoAnd publishing sex tapes is an encouragingly good predictor of failure. The system isn't perfect but I think it worked this time.
- zem 10y agothe question wasn't whether he used his powers for good this time, but whether it's good that he has those powers at all
- leereeves 10y agoWhat I object to here isn't Peter Thiel funding the lawsuit, but the system that forced Hulk Hogan to turn to him for help. In a perfect world, Hogan should have been able to pursue this lawsuit without outside funding. It's interesting that Reuters is attacking Peter Thiel for this. "Justice" has long been for sale. Is the old guard merely afraid of new players in the game?
- zem 10y agothere i definitely agree with you. before thiel intervened it was gawker who had the money and hogan who did not, and as you note, justice was equally for sale.
- CPLX 10y ago> system that forced Hulk Hogan to turn to him for help That doesn't seem like a reasonable interpretation of what happened. Hogan is a wealthy celebrity, and even if he wasn't the case was an obvious one to qualify for a contingency fee arrangement. Gawker was insured against a judgement, and they also apparently offered an eight figure settlement amount. Thiel's involvement wasn't needed for the lawsuit to exist, it was used to make the lawsuit into an attempt to bankrupt the company.
- leereeves 10y agoMy opinion: in a perfect world, no one would be forced to settle for less than they are legally entitled to simply because they can't afford to pursue the case to its conclusion in court.
- CPLX 10y ago> forced to settle for less than they are legally entitled to That's fine for some kinds of cases, but the exercise here was to value the economic consequences of the release of a tape of him having sex with someone. The actual amount of money one is legally entitled to for that is basically the definition of a subjective wild ass guess, let's not add fake precision to the analysis.
- xenadu02 10y agoAgain, that's depressingly naive. If journalists call out Billionaire X for some bad behavior... Just buy the paper and fire those people. Or fund an endless stream of lawsuits to silence them. That's the bigger picture here: Theil is trying to put a news outlet he doesn't like out of business. Even if he's totally justified the next 10 cases may not be but you can bet people will get the picture: don't piss off the SV billionaire club.
- leereeves 10y agoYou know that calling a different opinion naive isn't actually an argument, right? The mere possibility of a slippery slope doesn't show that Peter Thiel did anything wrong here. I hope other websites should learn not to publish something they don't have the legal right to publish.
- bduerst 10y agoThe argument behind why it's a naive perspective was made in the parent comment.
- leereeves 10y agoAm I alone in thinking insults like naive don't belong in discussions on Hacker News? No one's denying that wealthy people are powerful, but that's so well known that it's hardly worth discussing. Not all power is equal. Thiel is powerful; Gawker was powerful; neither comes close to the power of the government, or the established media, or the old money that quietly dominates most everything outside SV.
- bduerst 10y agoAd hom attacks aren't fallacious when relating to the credibility of statements and when they are backed up by reasoning. Blatant name calling isn't welcome, but saying something is naive and then taking the time to explain why and without malice shouldn't be censored.