3 ms·
Not a motorcycle. This is an electric bicycle. Forgetting the weight of the bike, that front brake isn't enough to properly handle the mass of a rider panic-b
by sandworm101 10y ago
Not a motorcycle. This is an electric bicycle. Forgetting the weight of the bike, that front brake isn't enough to properly handle the mass of a rider panic-braking at 100kph.
Also, look into modern Japanese motorcycle design. Their frames are much less than 6kg. Many don't have anything worthy of being called a frame. The rear swing arm is bolted to the engine block, with the only load-bearing structure being between that and the triple clamp (The bit where the front forks attach).
These are proper electric motorcycles:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TT_Zero https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TT_Zero
And here is what they can do:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlxZs2-gICc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlxZs2-gICc
- lisivka 10y agoBicycle is powered by human muscles only. Bicycle with a motor is called moped: https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/68/8a/8b/688a8b384aaa251d074c278bc450e6d4.jpg https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/68/8a/8b/688a8b384... .
- sandworm101 10y agoI'd say that bicycle means only two-wheeled, as opposed to tricycles and quads. Mopeds legally need pedals, which this does not have. Bicycles do not need pedals as various types don't have them. (I see kids at the beach every day on small bikes without pedals.) So without pedals it isn't a moped. And without any of the equipment to make it a street worthy or even a legal motorcycle, I call it a bicycle.
- Rumudiez 10y agoGoing by a legal definition, a moped can only be a two wheeled vehicle with a displacement smaller than 50cc for gas engines and a top speed lower than 35mph. Anything else is a motorcycle, including most scooters. Being legally registered and titled is a different matter than being simply described. I think motorcycle is exact and correct given the styling and capabilities of the bike.
- sandworm101 10y agoBut will you get a ticket for riding/parking it as a "motorcycle"? Without indicators and other regulated features, it wouldn't be allowed on the street as a motorcycle, or even a moped. I don't think it would qualify as a dirt bike for off-road either as there are many regs there too. Can you ride it in bicycle lanes? If it is anything other than a bicycle I don't see where one would be allowed to use it.
- lisivka 10y agoIf speed of this "electric bike" will be limited to below 35km/h, it will be legally allowed to drive public roads as "moped". Otherwise, it is not allowed for public roads at all, until it will meet safety requirements for motorcycle.
- sandworm101 10y agoIf anyone here is interested in design, look into what I meant by Japanese bikes. Motorcycles, all of them, can be divided into those with integrated engines and those with engines sitting inside frames. In Japan, where the entire bike was built by the same people and was meant for export, the result was engines with parts bolted on to create a bike. There are all sorts of weight/reliability advantages in doing this. In the west, the engine was built at a different factory and sat on mounts inside the frame ... exactly like the arrangement in the OP here. So whenever you see a two-wheeled vehicle with an engine wrapped inside a larger frame, know that it was the result of a very different development process.
- cb18 10y agolook into what I meant by Japanese bikes. Do you have any links or more specific search terms?
- sandworm101 10y ago"The big four" are Honda, Suzuki, Yamaha and Kawasaki. This group does on occasion act together, specifically when a few years ago there was an agreement to limit bikes to 300kph in reaction to the Hayabusa and associated tech that suggested a topspeed war was about to happen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzuki_Hayabusa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzuki_Hayabusa It's a great bike. A true monster but also easy to ride, particularly for short people. So everyone knew a faster bike was on the horizon.
- cb18 10y agoI was curious about the variance in the design you mentioned, reading the comment again, I got more of what you meant. So this is something unique to all Japanese bikes and has been something of a mainstay? At first read through, I mistakenly got the idea this was some new innovation. But now I get what you were saying about how these companies are vertically integrated much like Apple, so all components of the product can be more tightly integrated. So what would you say the main advantages here are? The bike can perform better in terms of handling because all parts are designed to work most effectively with the others? How much does the engine shape/design vary with Japanese bikes compared to bikes of other origins? Different attachment points with the engine to the other components? Do you know of any pictures of a Japanese bike without the body shell/faring on it, or just the bare frame? Quick Edit: Do you have any opinion on what you think the best Japanese touring and/or dual sport bikes are?
- lj3 10y agoThe difference between an electric bicycle and an electric motorcycle is academic these days. Take a look at this video[0]. Luke Workman, the lead battery designer at Zero Motorcycles, built an electric bike capable of out drag racing a Tesla model S P85. Taking the bike to full throttle tends to shear off the spokes in the rear wheel. I will agree the thing in the link isn't meant to see the road. It's a pretty art project. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnGvSEcldzQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnGvSEcldzQ
- swimfar 10y ago"Not a motorcycle. This is an electric bicycle. Forgetting the weight of the bike, that front brake isn't enough to properly handle the mass of a rider panic-braking at 100kph." I don't how someone could objectively say this is not a motorcycle. Is acceleration or braking performance how we classify whether something is a motorcycle or not? I'm sure there have been 100's of thousands of "real" motorcycles produced with worse braking than the disk brakes on this one. Old motorcycles (and cars) are notorious for having poor braking performance. I doubt a 5" single-leading-shoe front brake with 60's technology pads would do better than this. Some people put even smaller front brakes on choppers in the 60's. And certain kinds of motorcycle racing doesn't even allow brakes. Yeah, it uses many bicycle components. But I think people underestimate the amount of abuse a downhill bicycle is designed to take. It has a double triple clamp front fork with 35mm stanchions (fork tubes). Bad landings from a big jump would put way more energy into the fork than any normal street riding. If this were supposed to be an off-road motorcycle, I could understand the concerns. But for a street bike I wouldn't be at all afraid of riding it at 100 kph. Are there any modern motorcycles that it can outperform? Maybe not, but with it's low mass I wouldn't be too sure. And I don't think that's relevant anyways. It's a motorized two-wheeled vehicle with no pedals. There aren't too many more classification requirements one could add. And without pedals, it's certainly not a bicycle.