2 ms·
> Why? Many cases brought by individuals or groups on moral grounds have led the way to better governance. Intent matters. One of capitalism's great powers is
by wpietri 10y ago
> Why? Many cases brought by individuals or groups on moral grounds have led the way to better governance.
Intent matters. One of capitalism's great powers is harnessing the greedy and power-hungry and getting them to at least sometimes work for society. (It's not perfect, but it's better to have Bill Gates trying for a monopoly than starting land wars.) But that doesn't make them great-souled public benefactors. (Although later they do sometimes become that as well.)
Here we can infer intent from design. If Peter Thiel's goal was to help out defenseless individuals harmed by thoughtless journalists, that suggests one set of structures. E.g., a public nonprofit that does advocacy while funding the occasional suit from someone without money or power.
The structure actually chosen was to secretly fund a series of suits against a single publisher with the apparent intent of driving them out of business. The first plaintiff chosen was already rich (net worth, $25m) and famous. And if you talk to journalists, the result isn't to make them generally more careful. It's to make them more afraid of Thiel and other billionaires. [1]
So either A) Thiel is a kind-spirited public benefactor who's just not very competent or B) he's getting exactly the effect he wanted, which was to hopefully crush Denton and scare anybody who plans to write about him, even when the articles they write are perfectly legal. He seems like s smart guy, so I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt and going with B.
[1] e.g.: http://www.wired.com/2016/05/three-cheers-for-peter-thiel/ http://www.wired.com/2016/05/three-cheers-for-peter-thiel/
- dpark 10y ago> If Peter Thiel's goal was to help out defenseless individuals harmed by thoughtless journalists, that suggests one set of structures. E.g., a public nonprofit This has popped up several times in this thread, and I don't see why it's true. There's no obligation, legal or moral, that philanthropy be coordinated through a nonprofit. The only reason for the nonprofit is to get tax advantages. If you're donating tens of million of dollars to a nonprofit, it'll be to one where you wield significant control (officially or not). If Thiel's actions here were inappropriate, they'd be exactly as inappropriate if managed through a nonprofit.
- wpietri 10y ago"E.g." means "for example". By which I mean: there are a bunch of ways he could do this, and I was suggesting one. Also note that I said other words than "nonprofit" that are part of the example that I expected people to generalize from. But to yield to your nitpicking for a moment, your last sentence is wrong. Nonprofits have public disclosure requirements and state audits to make sure that they are acting to actually benefit the public. So him putting tens of millions into a nonprofit would be a) inherently less wrong, because they would not have been secret, and b) likely to be yet less wrong, in that they would have had to face substantial scrutiny from public servants.
- dpark 10y agoI agree that there are a bunch of ways he could do this. What I don't agree is that any of those other ways are inherently more moral. The morality of an action is independent of the legal structure erected around that action. You might prefer a non-profit or some other structure that doesn't make it easy for Thiel to hide his involvement, but the reality is that none of that matters morally (or legally, really). Bad actions don't become good because a non-profit manages them and good actions don't become bad when they are performed by private citizens. Your ideas about non-profits being "less wrong" are just incorrect. Privacy and secrecy are not immoral things. A non-profit structure would be more transparent but that doesn't make it "less wrong". Secrecy can hide bad actions but can also make possible good ones. e.g. An ex-con (or at the more extreme end, a Nazi) who wants to donate to cancer research might have his public donation rejected on moral grounds. The donation is moral even if the person has engaged in other immoral acts. A secret donation is therefore more moral in this case because it is more likely to be accepted. More immediately relevant, Thiel's public backing of the suit might have made a win less likely, meaning that if funding the suit is moral, funding it privately was the more effective and therefore more moral option.
- wpietri 10y agoYou seem to be very excited to argue about a variety of points I'm not actually making. Your secret-Nazi fantasies notwithstanding, I see this aa pretty simple reverse engineering. If his goal is to change how journalists behave, there are effective, well-known ways to do that. I believe his approach is inconsistent with that, but perfectly consistent with a personal vendetta. If your carefully considered analysis of approaches to social change differs, well, it differs. I'm ok with that.