3 ms·

When children are put in unnatural environments that are totally incompatible with the way children's minds actually work, they will not do well. Children shoul

When children are put in unnatural environments that are totally incompatible with the way children's minds actually work, they will not do well. Children should be actively learning, but school puts them in desks. I could have been diagnosed as ADHD in college. This was not a biological problem, but that I didn't care about my classes. Stimulants might have helped me focus better, but ... why? Robert Whitaker [1], author of Mad in America and Anatomy of an Epidemic, has looked into these matters, and concluded that the medications make people's conditions worse. [1] http://www.madinamerica.com/ http://www.madinamerica.com/

reitanqild 10y ago
> Robert Whitaker [1], author of Mad in America and Anatomy of an Epidemic, has looked into these matters, and concluded that the medications make people's conditions worse. Sure, I agree that the school isn't making it any better but lashing out against the things that work in lessening the pain given our current theoretical overload? Remember, we don't need to go further back than my childhood before woodworking and sewing was a school subject, as was cooking (yeap, real food: fish, meat and vegs). One generation back and my dad grew up with a work horse, dairy cows, dairy goats and sheep. And so on and so on. Evolution doesn't move that fast. Banning or further restricting (i.e. beyond todays standard where you need something line 7 years of medical scool) the best solutions we have doesn't sound like something I would support.
- teslabox 10y ago
  > Banning or further restricting [...] the best solutions we have doesn't sound like something I would support. The solutions offered by the medical profession are far from the best solutions we have, they're what are profitable for the medical-industrial establishment to offer.
  - reitanqild 10y ago
    > The solutions offered by the medical profession are far from the best solutions we have... I'm all ears: Tell me about it because I know someone who really did try without and would be happy if there was a better way.

reitanqild 10y ago

> Robert Whitaker [1], author of Mad in America and Anatomy of an Epidemic, has looked into these matters, and concluded that the medications make people's conditions worse. Sure, I agree that the school isn't making it any better but lashing out against the things that work in lessening the pain given our current theoretical overload? Remember, we don't need to go further back than my childhood before woodworking and sewing was a school subject, as was cooking (yeap, real food: fish, meat and vegs). One generation back and my dad grew up with a work horse, dairy cows, dairy goats and sheep. And so on and so on. Evolution doesn't move that fast. Banning or further restricting (i.e. beyond todays standard where you need something line 7 years of medical scool) the best solutions we have doesn't sound like something I would support.

teslabox 10y ago
> Banning or further restricting [...] the best solutions we have doesn't sound like something I would support. The solutions offered by the medical profession are far from the best solutions we have, they're what are profitable for the medical-industrial establishment to offer.
- reitanqild 10y ago
  > The solutions offered by the medical profession are far from the best solutions we have... I'm all ears: Tell me about it because I know someone who really did try without and would be happy if there was a better way.